Critics’ reviews

American Graffiti (1973)

14 reviews from 14 publications. Critics’ score 81: 13 positive, 1 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of American Graffiti

81
Positive
13
Mixed
1
Negative
0

Most critics respond warmly to American Graffiti, praising George Lucas’s sympathetic account of adolescence and its balance of comedy and melancholy. The praise clusters around the young cast, believable dialogue and the recreation of teenage life through cars, radio and music. The soundtrack is repeatedly singled out, alongside the film’s feel for a passing era. The Times particularly admires Harrison Ford’s charisma, while several reviews credit Lucas with keeping the nostalgia affectionate without tipping into camp.

The differences concern how much depth lies beneath that affection. Enthusiasm ranges from emphatic praise to more qualified approval, with only one mixed assessment and no negative reviews. The AV Club finds the feeling persuasive but some complexity lacking. The New Yorker supplies the clearest dissent: it admires the look and warmth but finds the comedy slow and its fondness for adolescence self-regarding, with little resonance beyond the jukebox.

Empire
1 January 2011
90*

The critic describes it as an instant classic perfectly attuned to the mood of early 70s baby boomers. It singles out the film's launch of many acting careers and its funny-serious tone with gorgeous cars, colours, and an amazing feel for the artefacts of an instantly vanished era.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
11 August 1973 · Roger Ebert
90*

Ebert finds the film a brilliant work of historical fiction that vividly recalls the innocence and cultural instant of 1962 teenagers cruising Main Street and listening to Wolfman Jack. He singles out its buried structure showing an innocence in the process of being lost, symbolized by the elusive blonde in the white Thunderbird.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
1 August 2017 · Alan R. Howard
90*

The critic calls it the freshest American movie in years and potentially a watershed film. He singles out the spirited dialogue, precise recreation of the era, strong casting, and Lucas's achievement in making a nostalgic film that avoids camp.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
5 August 1973 · Stephen Farber
90*

Farber declares it easily the best movie of the year and the most important American movie since Five Easy Pieces or Bonnie and Clyde, a lasting work of art with a definitive portrait of adolescence. He praises Lucas for bringing the past alive with sympathy, affection, and thorough understanding on a tight budget and schedule.

Read the full review →
The Times
12 February 2021 · ★★★★☆ · Kevin Maher
90*

The critic calls it a landmark teen drama and vital part of American cinema history, a love letter to rock’n’roll radio, drag racing and small-town life. They single out Harrison Ford’s star-making charismatic performance as a highlight.

Read the full review →
Variety
20 June 1973 · A.D. Murphy
90*

Murphy calls it among the very best youth-themed nostalgia films, a vivid recall of teenage attitudes told with outstanding empathy and compassion through a talented cast. He praises the first-rate Americana, superior screenplay, and masterful direction by Lucas.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
11 August 2023 · Daniel Allen
85*

The critic praises American Graffiti as a seminal and influential coming-of-age film that redefined the genre and launched careers, highlighting its innovative use of nostalgia through music, cars, and autobiographical elements as the key to its lasting impact.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
1 June 2011 · B+ · Scott Tobias
83

The review highlights the film's profound bittersweet epilogue revealing the characters' fates and its strong depth of feeling as a personal nostalgia piece. It notes some complexity is lacking compared to later films but praises the heartfelt quality and opportunity to see an earlier Lucas.

Read the full review →
Time Out
5 July 2012 · GA
80*

The review describes it as the film that launched many careers, noting its funny, perceptive portrayal of teenage life in 1962 California, enhanced by a great soundtrack and skillful parallel editing, while praising its controlled nostalgia that inspired many imitations.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
8 November 2023 · Jake Cole
70*

The critic views the film as the ur-text of the nostalgia movie, praising its believable voices of youth on the cusp of adulthood and loving recreation of the era's details. He singles out the revelation about Wolfman Jack as a poignant moment underscoring transience and corporatization.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
11 August 2023
70*

The critic finds the film a loose, episodic hangout comedy about California teens on one nostalgic summer night in 1962 that is laced with subtle melancholy, especially in its postscript revealing the characters' fates. They single out the evocative soundtrack and the way it captures a fleeting era just before major cultural shifts.

Read the full review →
The New Yorker
29 October 1973 · Penelope Gilliatt
50*

Gilliatt finds the film a warm, nice, draggy comedy with a sensual understanding of film and appealing look and feel, but faults it for lacking resonance beyond the jukebox and for its pop narcissism inviting a fond view of adolescence. She notes the audience's ecstatic condescension toward its own past.

Read the full review →
Collider
3 May 2023 · Danny Cox
90*

The critic argues that American Graffiti represents George Lucas's artistic peak and best film, surpassing even Star Wars in emotional depth and human connection. They single out its mix of comedy and melancholy, along with innovative sound design and cinematography, as what makes the nostalgic coming-of-age story timeless and resonant.

Read the full review →
Consequence
11 August 2023
70*

The piece frames American Graffiti as a warm, funny turning point in Lucas's career after the cold THX 1138, crediting Coppola's influence for helping it succeed as a slice-of-life comedy. It singles out the film's powerful nostalgia and the young cast's performances as what make its 50th anniversary celebration especially moving.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate