Critics’ reviews

Anatomy of a Fall (2023)

25 reviews from 25 publications. Critics’ score 87: 14 positive, 0 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of Anatomy of a Fall

87
Positive
14
Mixed
0
Negative
0

The reviews for Anatomy of a Fall are uniformly positive, and the spread is narrow: nobody files a mixed or negative notice, and the disagreement is over degree, not direction. Most critics arrive at the same two points. The first is Sandra Hüller, whose performance as the accused writer is described as poised, unreadable and open, carrying every possible reading of the character. The second is Justine Triet’s screenplay, praised for the exactness of its trial logistics and for using the courtroom to take a marriage apart rather than to solve a crime. Several critics note that the film leaves its central question unanswered and count that as a virtue. The reservations are small and scattered. Little White Lies finds it offers less that is new than its polish suggests, Paste thinks Triet holds back from bolder moves, and Screen Daily and Empire mention a slow start and a long runtime. Nobody thinks these outweigh the rest.

Financial Times
9 November 2023 · ★★★★★ · Danny Leigh
100

The review calls it a superlative thriller of gravity and complexity, with Sandra Hüller's authentic star turn driving a modern courtroom story full of doubt and Hitchcockian wit. The film's forensic details and emotional depth are highlighted.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
9 November 2023 · ★★★★★ · Tim Robey
100

The review hails the film as a sparkling intellectual thriller with a diamond script that explores every detail of the case and relationship with precision. Hüller's masterful performance and the film's lingering wizardry are singled out for praise.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
12 October 2023 · A- · Courtney Howard
90

Triet crafts a fresh courtroom procedural that sustains suspense while dissecting a marriage and family dynamics through layered sound design and performances. Hüller delivers a towering, nuanced turn as the accused writer whose identity is scrutinized.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
12 November 2023 · Peter Bradshaw
90*

The critic praises the film's gripping, intricate screenplay and dynamic courtroom drama that keeps audiences guessing about a marriage and a suspicious death. Sandra Hüller's compelling performance anchors the story's exploration of bias and ambiguity.

Read the full review →
Empire
7 November 2023 · Laura Venning
85*

The film is a gripping family drama that disguises itself as a murder mystery while dissecting the disintegration of a marriage. It singles out the strong ensemble cast and perceptive script for maintaining momentum despite the long runtime and ambiguity.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
10 November 2023 · Sophie Monks Kaufman
85*

This gorgeously poised psychodrama functions as a court procedural and character study that interrogates how female guilt is judged by likeability. It singles out Sandra Hüller’s enigmatic, poised performance as carrying every possible reading of the central character.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
10 November 2023 · 4/4/3 · David Jenkins
80

The critic calls it compelling Hitchcockian hokum with immaculately precise plotting that poses an existential conundrum about culpability and truth. It singles out Sandra Hüller's technically astounding central performance while noting the film offers less that is new than its formal pleasures suggest.

Read the full review →
The i Paper
10 November 2023 · Christina Newland
80*

The Palme d’Or winner is an utterly unconventional and slow-burn courtroom drama that leaves its biggest questions unanswered yet remains compelling and satisfying. It singles out the meticulous exploration of trial logistics and chronology alongside standout performances, particularly Sandra Hüller’s sphinx-like turn.

Read the full review →
Time Out
21 May 2023 · ★★★★
80

The critic finds it a captivating and emotionally searing Alpine murder-mystery that blends Rear Window with Marriage Story. It praises the film's psychological and emotional depth, complex characters, and treatment of marriage as a prime suspect in the whodunit.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
13 October 2023 · Justin Chang

The Palme d’Or winner is a superb, ambiguous courtroom drama that demolishes notions of empirical truth in a marriage. The critic singles out Sandra Hüller’s brilliant, nuanced performance as the standout element.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
21 May 2023 · festival review

The critic notes a rewarding Palme d’Or-winning courtroom drama that conveys a complicated woman through an intriguing trial narrative. It highlights Sandra Hüller's nuanced central performance in a twisty, thought-provoking film that gains dramatic traction after a slow start.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
29 May 2023 · festival review

The critic describes the film as a gripping, sharply intelligent psychological drama centered on a trial that dissects a marriage and questions of responsibility and passion. It highlights the nuanced central performance by Sandra Hüller and the searing screenplay's examination of professional jealousy and relational dynamics.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
21 May 2023 · festival review · Jon Frosch

Triet delivers a gripping, richly layered drama about a writer on trial for her husband's murder that explores the unknowability of people and relationships. The critic praises Hüller's sensational lead performance and the film's nuanced take on legal assumptions and storytelling.

Read the full review →
The New Yorker
6 October 2023 · Anthony Lane

Triet’s slippery thriller excels at generating uncertainty about a marriage and a death through meticulous scrutiny of evidence and testimony. The critic highlights the masterful performances, especially Hüller’s, and the film’s refusal to resolve its puzzles neatly.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
12 October 2023 · Amy Nicholson

The film is a cerebral trial drama that keeps the audience off-balance by focusing on the question of guilt rather than providing an answer. The critic praises the way it dissects the flaws and contradictions of an ordinary woman under scrutiny.

Read the full review →
The Times
10 November 2023 · ★★★★☆ · Kevin Maher

The critic notes the film's prestige makeover of courtroom thriller clichés, shifting focus to the brutality of intimacy in a marriage. The impeccable screenplay and strong performances deliver a show-stopping trial.

Read the full review →
Vulture
17 October 2023 · Bilge Ebiri

The film is a courtroom thriller and marital drama that probes whether we can ever fully know or grasp the truth amid shifting perceptions and resentments. Ebiri highlights the central fight scene and Hüller's performance walking the line between open and unreadable.

Read the full review →
Collider
2 June 2023 · A · Therese Lacson
95

The critic finds the Palme d'Or winner a gripping and enigmatic story about perception, truth, and ambition that stands out as one of the best films of Cannes. Sandra Hüller's compelling performance and the story's intricate details make it worthy of a rewatch.

Read the full review →
Deadline
21 May 2023 · festival review · Damon Wise
90*

Triet's film is a ferociously intelligent and deceptively playful drama that uses genre as a Trojan horse to explore a family's sudden implosion. It centers on Sandra Hüller's tour de force performance as a writer whose innocence is tested in a meticulously deconstructed courtroom setting.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
21 May 2023 · festival review · Steve Pond
85*

Triet's sophisticated film keeps characters and audience off balance with its direct style and deliberate ambiguity in a story blending family drama, whodunit and courtroom elements. It is tense yet subtle and satisfying, with a richly textured central performance from Sandra Hüller.

Read the full review →
The Ringer
31 May 2023 · festival review
80*

The critic highlights the film's exploration of toxic influence, gender dynamics, and how the trial exposes the messiness of a marriage beyond simple victim-or-perpetrator framing. It draws comparisons to real-life cases like The Staircase for its suspense and unresolved questions.

Read the full review →
The Skinny
20 June 2023 · ★★★★ · Jojo Ajisafe
80

The critic praises the film's complex portrayal of a couple's troubled relationship and the compelling performances, especially Sandra Hüller's, while noting how it subverts the courtroom drama genre with ambiguity and focus on characters rather than the crime.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
10 November 2023 · Amber Wilkinson

The slowburn drama keeps the question of guilt or innocence hanging while getting to the heart of the couple’s relationship. Hüller’s unfussy performance allows the character’s ambiguities to shine as the film focuses on how evidence affects the son.

Read the full review →
Film Stories
7 November 2023 · Maria Lattila

The critic finds the Palme d’Or winner a taut and smart drama with a fascinating murder mystery that flows well despite its length. Triet’s precise direction creates tension through gender and marital dynamics explored in the courtroom proceedings.

Read the full review →
Paste
20 October 2023 · 8.0 · Katarina Docalovich

The critic calls it one of the most sharply made courtroom dramas in recent memory, praising its interrogation of a marriage and especially the child's grief arc and performance. Triet's refusal to fully commit to bolder moves or gut punches is noted as a limitation.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate