Critics’ reviews

Animal Kingdom (2010)

19 reviews from 19 publications. Critics’ score 84: 5 positive, 1 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of Animal Kingdom

84
Positive
5
Mixed
1
Negative
0

Most critics welcome Animal Kingdom as an assured crime drama, with praise centred on David Michôd’s direction and the ensemble. Jacki Weaver’s chilling matriarch and Ben Mendelsohn’s unstable Pope attract particular attention. The reviews repeatedly single out the oppressive family relationships, naturalistic detail and brooding atmosphere: the threat within the home matters as much as the criminal activity outside it. Many find that this domestic focus gives a familiar genre fresh tension.

The disagreement concerns how far that assurance carries the story. The AV Club admires the plotting and supporting performances but finds the teenage lead lacking in charisma. Den of Geek praises the first half, then finds the second sluggish and increasingly clichéd. Slant Magazine is a sharper dissenter, rejecting the film’s seriousness as pretentious and its appeal for empathy as unearned. Enthusiasm predominates, but the dissent extends beyond pacing to the film’s treatment of its characters.

Little White Lies
25 February 2011 · 3/5/5 · Jason Wood
100

Michôd’s assured debut stakes a claim as a modern classic with its authentic, naturalistic account of Melbourne’s criminal landscape. The ensemble cast, especially Jacki Weaver as the chilling matriarch, delivers first-rate performances.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
13 August 2010 · B+ · Noel Murray
83

Sort of like an Australian Goodfellas with less sweep and more grubbiness, the film tracks a teenage orphan’s introduction to a life of low-level crime. It is stylish and sharply plotted, with strong performances from Weaver and Mendelsohn offsetting a charisma-free hero.

Read the full review →
Time Out
22 February 2011 · Dave Calhoun
80*

This cocky, eye-grabbing debut brings a Scorsese-like energy to the story of a Melbourne crime family. Michôd makes a well-worn genre feel fresh and thoughtful with its distinctive sense of the grotesque and stylish dread.

Read the full review →
Empire
14 January 2011 · Damon Wise

Michôd’s film is praised as a sombre, slick revival of the gangster genre that focuses on emotional violence and family dynamics rather than action or comedy. The critic highlights excellent performances, particularly Jacki Weaver as the ruthless matriarch Smurf, and calls it a rarity that makes one wish for more such films.

Read the full review →
Film Comment

The critic praises David Michôd’s assured and intelligent debut as a gripping criminal-family tale that stands out from standard crime dramas. Standout elements include the electrifying performances, particularly Ben Mendelsohn as the unstable Pope.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
13 August 2010 · Kenneth Turan

The critic describes the film as a moody, brooding modern film noir and impressive debut that is both laconic and operatic. It singles out the careful craftsmanship, including cinematography, lighting, sound design and score, for creating a malignant atmosphere of menace.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
31 January 2010 · festival review

Michôd makes an exciting and assured feature debut with this wrenching Melbourne-set gangster saga about a teenager coming of age in a crime family. The lean script and flawless ensemble cast, especially Jacki Weaver, stand out.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
· Wally Hammond

Michôd’s debut is an ambitious and effective thriller exploring Australia’s criminal underbelly through the decline of an old-fashioned crime family. The best scenes capture the claustrophobic family home and the characters’ paranoia with gritty realism.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
8 August 2010 · Nick Schager

The film wrongly assumes certain characters deserve empathy simply because they’re protagonists. It is a conventional Melbourne crime film awash in unwarranted pretentiousness, with derivative posturing and no surprises beyond one early death.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
24 February 2011 · Peter Bradshaw

The film is a tense, violent and supremely watchable study of a dysfunctional crime family on the verge of imploding. It singles out Ben Mendelsohn's chilling performance as the sociopathic Pope Cody for particular praise.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
14 October 2010 · festival review · Kirk Honeycutt

The film is a brooding, intimate, clear-eyed look at the precipitous downfall of a family in the Melbourne underworld. It offers a naturalistic drama rich in psychology and attention to details, marking an auspicious directing debut.

Read the full review →
The Independent
27 February 2011

The critic finds the film a low-key but tense portrait of a Melbourne crime family where the real horror lies in what relatives will do to each other. Strong performances, especially from newcomers and Ben Mendelsohn as the menacing Pope, drive the story of a teenager caught between kin and the law.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
13 August 2010 · Stephen Holden

The critic calls the film a mostly terrific Australian gangster story about a ruthless matriarch ruling over her sociopathic sons in suburban Melbourne. It highlights the intense, jungle-like family dynamics and sudden violence as the standout elements.

Read the full review →
Variety
28 January 2010 · festival review · Todd McCarthy

The critic praises the ambitious and powerful study of an Australian crime family's disintegration, orchestrated with operatic and Greek dimensions in an unusually accomplished debut. It highlights the confident direction, strong performances especially by Weaver and Mendelsohn, and the brooding style that builds dread.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
27 May 2010 · A- · Simon Dang
90

It is a gripping, atmospheric, haunting slow-burn tale of loyalty and revenge with standout performances from Ben Mendelsohn and Jacki Weaver, strong direction, and a Greek tragedy feel in an Australian crime drama setting.

Read the full review →
/Film
30 January 2010 · festival review · David Chen
85*

Animal Kingdom is a slow but worthwhile burn with brooding atmosphere, naturalistic dialogue, and brilliant use of soundtrack; it recalls Greek tragedy in its themes of revenge and is riveting, thrilling, and heartbreaking.

Read the full review →
Den of Geek
25 February 2011 · ★★★ · N P
60

The first half is powerful, gripping and well-handled with excellent performances across the board, but the second half slows, becomes sluggish and descends into clichés. It remains a solid and engaging crime story overall despite feeling disjointed.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
17 February 2011 · Owen Van Spall

Michôd creates a deeply pessimistic but fascinating world with excellent performances from the cast, particularly the Cody family dynamics, strong atmosphere, cinematography, and score; the only way to survive is by the law of the jungle.

Read the full review →
HeyUGuys
25 February 2011 · Jamie Neish

The critic praises the film's extraordinary acting, directing, and ensemble performances, especially Jacki Weaver as the matriarch Smurf, calling it a compelling and beautifully executed crime drama.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate