Most critics praise Au Revoir les Enfants as a moving, unsentimental account of childhood friendship under occupation. The praise centres on Malle’s handling of the two boys: their growing attachment feels truthful, while the changing balance between them gives the school drama tension. The reviews also value the detail of everyday boarding-school life and the restraint with which Malle brings the adult world’s cruelty into view, drawing emotional force from personal memory without resorting to melodrama.
There is no clear dissent, and the scored reviews sit within a fairly narrow positive range. Differences concern emphasis rather than substantial reservations: Time Out stresses the shifting power within the friendship and the film’s departure from familiar boarding-school stories. The Evening Standard places its emotional power above its ideas, while other reviews give greater weight to moral complexity and the precision of Malle’s recollections.
