The reviews are almost uniformly warm, with fourteen of fifteen positive and none negative. The praise clusters on the animation: the watercolour and impressionistic backgrounds, the seasonal and storm sequences, and the way the film shifts from comedy to dread without losing its footing. Thumper is named again and again as the character who carries the lighter passages. Most critics also single out the death of Bambi’s mother, admiring its restraint and how much it does offscreen, and several read the film as a quiet study of nature’s cycles and innocence lost.
The spread is narrow, and the dissent is mostly old. The New Yorker, writing in 1942, finds the characterisation and comedy short of Disney’s earlier features and the animals too talkative. The New York Times, the same year, feels it drifts too far into realistic naturalism when it should be cartoon fantasy. Among later critics, only Slant Magazine finds the themes thin beside other Disney films of the period.
