Most critics praise Black Narcissus for making colour, landscape and studio artifice express the desires its characters cannot acknowledge. Jack Cardiff’s Technicolor cinematography, the matte paintings and the sets attract consistent admiration: the reviews see them as essential to the psychological drama, rather than decoration. Praise also clusters around Kathleen Byron’s performance, with Deborah Kerr drawing strong notices, while several critics value the film’s frank treatment of female desire and its attention to cultural tensions.
The disagreement concerns how much of this feverish melodrama the story can sustain. Variety admires the production and colour photography but finds lapses in the storytelling; the Los Angeles Times finds the sexual hysteria and atmosphere excessive. The spread is therefore wide, though the dissent is isolated: most critics regard the heightened emotion and visual intensity as the means by which Powell and Pressburger make repression visible.
