Most critics admire it, and the praise gathers first around Tom Cruise. Nearly every review calls his Ron Kovic a transformation, the star made convincing as a paralysed veteran stripped of dignity and turned into an activist. Stone’s ambition is the other point of agreement: reviewers see a wider canvas than Platoon, with Kovic’s journey from small-town patriot to protester standing for the country’s own loss of faith. The hospital sequences are singled out more than once.
The reservations are about Stone rather than Cruise. Several reviews find the film too long, too loud and given to sermonising, with heavy episodes and swelling music doing work the writing should. The two mixed notices push further: the Los Angeles Times argues it stirs the emotions without engaging the mind on how Kovic’s politics change, and The New Yorker finds it a scream of rage built from portentous blackouts. Nobody dismisses it; the spread runs from raves to grudging respect.
