Most critics agree that Cabaret is one of the few musicals that is also serious political film-making, following the rise of the Nazis in Weimar Berlin without softening it. The praise gathers around Bob Fosse’s decision to keep the numbers on the club stage and cut them against the life outside, and around the two central performances: Liza Minnelli’s Sally Bowles and Joel Grey’s Master of Ceremonies are named again and again. Several reviews credit the film with breaking the glossy Hollywood musical for good, and the design, lighting and colour are compared to Expressionist painting.
The spread is narrow, with ten of eleven reviews positive. The reservations sit almost entirely on the editing. Time Out calls the film a maddening mixture and finds the cross-cutting crude, pushing it into overstatement. The New York Times, writing on release, admires it a great deal but calls it imperfect and picks at details in Minnelli’s performance. Nobody disputes the numbers themselves.
