Most critics find Chocolat an agreeable fable, and half of them like it a good deal more than that. The praise clusters on the cast. Juliette Binoche is named in most reviews as the film’s calm centre, Alfred Molina’s mayor is repeatedly singled out, and Judi Dench’s landlady draws notice too. Lasse Hallström’s direction is described as light and assured, and the warmer reviews credit him with making something more substantial than the sugary premise suggests.
The spread is wide. The reservations all point the same way: it is too soft, too sweet and too eager to please, with little real conflict and a feel-good ending that some find patronising. The Guardian is the harshest, arguing that not even Binoche can save it, and the Evening Standard says the film blunts the sharper edges of the novel. Time Out adds that the period setting seals the story off from any present-day bite.
