Critics’ reviews

Chocolat (2000)

10 reviews from 10 publications. Critics’ score 61: 5 positive, 2 mixed, 3 negative.

Back to our review of Chocolat

61
Positive
5
Mixed
2
Negative
3

Most critics find Chocolat an agreeable fable, and half of them like it a good deal more than that. The praise clusters on the cast. Juliette Binoche is named in most reviews as the film’s calm centre, Alfred Molina’s mayor is repeatedly singled out, and Judi Dench’s landlady draws notice too. Lasse Hallström’s direction is described as light and assured, and the warmer reviews credit him with making something more substantial than the sugary premise suggests.

The spread is wide. The reservations all point the same way: it is too soft, too sweet and too eager to please, with little real conflict and a feel-good ending that some find patronising. The Guardian is the harshest, arguing that not even Binoche can save it, and the Evening Standard says the film blunts the sharper edges of the novel. Time Out adds that the period setting seals the story off from any present-day bite.

Los Angeles Times
15 December 2000 · Kevin Thomas
90*

The critic hails it as a delectable yet spiritually nourishing humanist fable with wide appeal. Hallström's subtle direction and the cast's glowing performances, especially Binoche and Molina, are singled out for praise.

Read the full review →
Variety
7 December 2000 · Lael Loewenstein
85*

The review describes it as a richly textured comic fable blending Old World wisdom with timely commentary on moral superiority. It praises Hallström's observations on the human spirit and the exquisite production values.

Read the full review →
Empire
1 January 2000 · Kim Newman
80*

Lasse Hallström brings a delicate touch to this blend of comedy, soap, romance and magic that feels like a souffle but turns out more substantial. It is a treat and a rare showcase for Binoche, though with the minor cavil of players speaking English with slight French accents.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
22 December 2000 · Roger Ebert
80*

The critic sees the film as a charming fable pitting pagan sensuality against rigid Christianity, with chocolate as the winning force. Binoche is singled out as a serene, wise presence who embodies the story's life-affirming spirit.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
15 December 2000 · Elvis Mitchell
60*

The review calls it a crowd-pleasing but manipulative confection, an art-house film for those who dislike art-house films. It praises the assured direction and strong ensemble performances, especially Molina and Depp.

Read the full review →
Time Out
10 September 2012 · WH
55*

Hallström's soft adaptation constructs a feminist parable about courage, support and pleasure in personal transformation, with excellent performances. However, their relevance is diminished by the historical bubble in which they are situated, with the period cinematography preserving the whole in aspic.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
15 December 2000 · Scott Tobias
40*

The critic finds Lasse Hallström's fable-like story of a chocolate shop disrupting a conservative French village overly sweet and lacking depth or conflict. While acknowledging the charm of its cast and progressive themes, the review criticizes its heavy-handed magic realism and emotional generosity as making the film insubstantial.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
10 April 2012
30*

Some audiences will like this soft-centred, simplistic pseudo-French fable better than the critic did; it is a predigested exercise in genteel nostalgia that neuters the source novel's sharper edges and reduces food to mere bon-bons rather than a transfigured sacrament.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
2 March 2001 · Peter Bradshaw
25*

The critic calls the film a gooey, sickly-sweet confection that even Juliette Binoche cannot redeem, comparing it unfavourably to a Thornton's factory and criticising its patronising feelgood ethos and Depp's performance. Binoche's grace and beauty are singled out for praise amid the complaints about the film's ickiness and smugness.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
9 March 2001 · Angus Wolfe Murray
70*

The critic describes it as a fairy story about a woman who provides a breath of fresh air to a small French town. Praises supporting performances like Alfred Molina as the mayor and Judi Dench as a grouchy landlady who learns to let go, while noting Juliette Binoche's character is more sentimental than exacting.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate