Critics’ reviews

Club Kid (2026)

13 reviews from 13 publications. Critics’ score 83: 13 positive, 0 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of Club Kid

83
Positive
13
Mixed
0
Negative
0

The reviews are uniformly positive about Club Kid, with praise clustering around its humour, warmth and affectionate depiction of New York’s queer nightlife. Most critics find Jordan Firstman’s debut unexpectedly tender, particularly in the relationship between Peter and Arlo. Firstman and Reggie Absolom’s chemistry draws repeated praise, as does dialogue that allows sharp comedy to give way to sadness without making the change feel forced. The club scenes are valued for their specificity and the sense of community around the central pair.

The differences concern how convincingly the film earns its sentiment. IndieWire and The Hollywood Reporter find Peter’s move towards caregiving or personal growth too easy, while Vulture considers him less fully realised than the supporting characters. Other reservations concern underwritten character details and a neat ending. The spread runs from enthusiastic to qualified approval rather than outright dissent: even the more reserved reviews find the film funny and affecting.

IndieWire
15 May 2026 · A- · Ryan Lattanzio
90

Lattanzio praises the film as a funny, poignant, crowd-pleasing debut that reveals Firstman as a sincere storyteller. He singles out the unexpectedly tender bond between Peter and Arlo, while noting that Peter’s quick turn toward caregiving feels abrupt.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
17 October 2026 · festival review
90*

The critic calls it a triumphant, accessible and profound debut that balances intimate sadness with feel-good sentiment. They especially praise the chemistry between Jordan Firstman and newcomer Reggie Absolom.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
5 October 2026 · festival review · Owen Myers
90*

The critic calls the film an irresistible, warmly observed gem, though its ending feels a little too neat. They praise its affectionate yet unsentimental portrait of queer nightlife and its characters.

Read the full review →
The New Yorker
26 May 2026 · festival review · Justin Chang
90*

Chang finds the film disarmingly sweet and hugely enjoyable, praising its bittersweet emotional payoff. He singles out Firstman’s assured camera work and ability to reveal depth beneath the film’s dazzling club-scene surface.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
festival review · Hannah Strong
85*

Strong finds the film a fiercely funny, warmly affecting story that ultimately recognizes the limits of escapism. She singles out Firstman’s comedic writing and the chemistry with first-time actor Reggie Absolom for praise.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
15 May 2026 · festival review · Wendy Ide
85*

The headline presents the film as a triumphant, acidic portrait of New York’s gay scene. It singles out that portrait of the scene as the film’s defining strength.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
4 November 2026 · Glenn Whipp
80*

Whipp finds the film a heartfelt, funny crowd-pleaser, despite some underdeveloped character details. He particularly praises the tender chemistry between Jordan Firstman and Reggie Absolom.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
21 September 2026 · ★★★/4 · Kyle Turner
75

Turner finds the film a warm, convincing take on growing up that makes familiar coming-of-age clichés feel personal. He particularly praises its vivid New York nightlife and the way it makes the competing appeals of club life and parenthood believable.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
15 May 2026 · festival review · Richard Lawson
75*

Lawson calls the film a confident, exciting directorial debut that turns its party-boy premise into a warm, clever story about fatherhood. He particularly praises the lively, natural rapport between Jordan Firstman and Reggie Absolom, while noting that the film makes Peter’s personal growth feel overly easy.

Read the full review →
Variety
16 May 2026 · festival review · Guy Lodge
75*

Lodge finds the film a sweet, unexpectedly earnest crowdpleaser, despite familiar first-feature shortcomings. He praises its sharp, salty dialogue and vivid depiction of New York’s queer club scene.

Read the full review →
Vulture
15 May 2026 · festival review · Alison Willmore
70*

Willmore finds the film funny, visually exuberant, and unexpectedly touching, though Peter remains less fully realized than the supporting characters. She especially praises the specificity and humor of the queer New York nightlife and its sharply drawn ensemble.

Read the full review →
Den of Geek
29 September 2026 · ★★★★½ · David Crow
90

Crow calls the film an irresistibly sweet, feel-good crowdpleaser, despite some underwritten aspects of Arlo’s story. He praises its warmth and good cheer, especially the father-and-son relationship and the performances.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
15 May 2026 · festival review · Elena Lazic
85*

Lazic finds the film funny, tender, and unexpectedly moving, with comedy that carries naturally into drama. She especially praises Firstman’s lively, nuanced dialogue and the honest connections between Peter, his son, and their queer community.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate