Critics’ reviews

Collective (2019)

16 reviews from 16 publications. Critics’ score 88: 16 positive, 0 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of Collective

88
Positive
16
Mixed
0
Negative
0

The reviews are unanimous: sixteen critics, sixteen positive verdicts, and most find Alexander Nanau’s documentary as gripping as a thriller. The praise clusters around the journalists’ patient investigation into Romania’s hospitals after the Colectiv nightclub fire, and around the access Nanau secures, particularly to the young reform-minded health minister. Several critics single out the same two moments: secretly filmed footage of maggots in a patient’s wound, and the survivor Tedy Ursuleanu. The observational style, with no narration, is repeatedly credited for the film’s force.

Reservations barely exist. Scores run from a lone 70 to a pair of full marks, and the lowest, from Screen Daily at the festival premiere, still calls the film accomplished and gripping; it simply praises more quietly. The only real difference is emphasis: The Independent and The Telegraph read it as a conspiracy thriller in the line of Spotlight or All the President’s Men, while Sight and Sound and Slant treat it as an argument about public responsibility and a free press.

Time Out
29 October 2020 · ★★★★★ · Phil de Semlyen
100

The review calls it a gripping, must-see documentary that expands the story of the nightclub fire into a takedown of a corrupt state, with forensic skill and quiet fury.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
19 November 2020 · Eric Kohn
90*

Alexander Nanau’s bracing documentary plays like a gripping real-time thriller about the fallout from a nightclub fire and the dark forces confronting journalism.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
18 November 2020 · Justin Chang
90*

The critic calls the film a brilliant, suspenseful exposé of medical malpractice and corruption with universal implications, especially timely during the pandemic. It singles out the journalists' dogged investigation and the young health minister's transparency efforts for praise.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
20 November 2020
90*

The critic praises the film's scalpel-like precision in exposing corruption in Romania's health service following the Colectiv fire, noting its observational style and universal relevance to public responsibility.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
17 November 2020 · A- · Noel Murray
90

The documentary is a taut, intense procedural that follows a journalistic investigation into Romania’s dysfunctional medical bureaucracy after a nightclub fire, exposing corruption while remaining emotionally wrenching.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
19 November 2020 · Peter Bradshaw
90*

The critic praises Nanau’s searing documentary for exposing Romania’s widespread healthcare corruption and gangsterism following the Colectiv fire, highlighting the heroic investigation by journalist Cătălin Tolontan. The review singles out the film’s depiction of bureaucratic indifference and a secretly filmed video of maggots in a patient’s wound as particularly horrifying.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
12 September 2019 · festival review · Deborah Young
90*

The film is a visceral exposé of hospital corruption following a deadly nightclub fire, reaching emotional depths through its observational style while celebrating sound investigative journalism.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
19 November 2020 · Critic’s Pick · Manohla Dargis
90*

The critic praises the documentary for its coherent and staggering account of the scandals following the 2015 nightclub fire and the journalists' investigation into hospital corruption. It singles out the resilience and story of survivor Tedy Ursuleanu for praise.

Read the full review →
The Times
18 November 2020 · ★★★★☆ · Kevin Maher
90*

The critic calls the documentary gripping and highlights its portrayal of intense investigative journalism uncovering wholesale corruption in Romania’s medical establishment after the Colectiv fire. It singles out the astounding access to key figures and Hollywood-style plot twists as standout features.

Read the full review →
The Independent
19 November 2020 · ★★★½/4 · Jake Coyle
88

The piercing documentary exposes government corruption in Romania's healthcare system following a nightclub fire and is as absorbing as Spotlight. It singles out the striking access to a reform-minded health minister and the grim visual metaphor of maggots in wounds for particular impact.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
16 November 2020 · Diego Semerene
85*

The film is a searing chronicle of institutional corruption that reminds viewers without investigative reporting there is no democracy, highlighting the collaborative nature and urgency of journalism in the face of horror.

Read the full review →
Variety
6 September 2019 · Critics Pick · Jay Weissberg
85*

The critic hails it as an explosive observational documentary exposing sickening corruption with resonance far beyond Romania. It singles out the focus on journalists uncovering diluted disinfectants and the universal themes of lies and lack of empathy for praise.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
19 November 2020
80*

The review describes how Nanau’s documentary follows journalists exposing layers of wrongdoing in Romania’s health system after the nightclub fire, likening it to conspiracy thrillers like All the President’s Men. It singles out the focus on health minister Vlad Voiculescu’s reform efforts as a key element.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
4 September 2019 · festival review
70*

Praises the accomplished documentary for its gripping investigative study of the fire and healthcare scandal, with a brisk narrative that promises exposure beyond festivals.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
22 November 2020 · A+ · Chris Barsanti
100

The critic calls the film a riveting drama of catastrophic amorality, commending its clear-eyed procedural approach to uncovering widespread corruption and its balance of professionalism with dark humor. It singles out the human cost and the tenacity of journalists and reformers.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
17 November 2020 · Amber Wilkinson
85*

The critic praises Nanau's damning documentary for exposing systemic corruption in Romania's healthcare system following the Colectiv nightclub fire, noting how little has changed since earlier Romanian films on the subject. It highlights the importance of a free press and the personal toll on reformers and survivors.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate