
Most critics warm to Kogonada’s debut, and they warm to it for the same reasons. The praise clusters on the way the film puts the modernist buildings of Columbus, Indiana, at the centre of a friendship rather than behind it, and on Haley Lu Richardson, whose performance is named again and again as the emotional core. John Cho is often mentioned alongside her. The composition and framing draw near-universal admiration, and Ozu is the comparison most reviews reach for.
The reservations are few and mild, and the spread is narrow, with almost every review landing in the same approving range. Where critics hesitate, it is over pace and thinness. Little White Lies finds the final act jarring; Time Out finds the story and performances less polished than the photography; The Wrap, the one plainly cool notice, complains that the minimalism leaves the characters underdeveloped. Nobody disputes that the film is carefully made. The question the dissenters raise is whether the care carries the story.
G
The Guardian
5 October 2018 · Peter Bradshaw
90*
The architecture is the star in this absorbing debut where Kogonada creates an engrossing and unexpectedly passionate film about feelings displaced into space and building materials. Haley Lu Richardson is outstanding as the young architecture buff who forms a friendship with John Cho's character.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
27 January 2017 · festival review · Boyd van Hoeij
90*
The critic calls it a soft-spoken and perceptive art-house treat that announces a new director blending small-scale Ozu-like humanism with impressive formalist command of film. Architecture is singled out as the key third ingredient that elevates the character drama into unexpected territory.
Read the full review →N
The New Yorker
9 June 2017 · festival review · Richard Brody
90*
Brody celebrates the film’s intellectual coming-of-age story centered on a young woman’s passionate engagement with Columbus, Indiana’s architectural treasures and her friendship with a visitor. He singles out Haley Lu Richardson’s performance for its emotional and intellectual acuity alongside Kogonada’s analytical visual approach.
Read the full review →T
The Times
5 October 2018 · ★★★★☆ · Kevin Maher
90*
Brainy and sensual, this wildly impressive feature debut is a coming-of-age drama that consistently defies expectation and is built on an indecently charismatic performance from Haley Lu Richardson. It is impeccably filmed with geometric precision.
Read the full review →F
Film Comment
festival review · Jonathan Romney
85*
The critic praises Kogonada’s debut as a strikingly distinctive and mature American film that celebrates architecture’s emotional power and everyday wonder through restrained, cerebral storytelling. It singles out Haley Lu Richardson’s radiant, rapturous performance as a highlight of intellectual and aesthetic passion.
Read the full review →F
Financial Times
3 October 2018 · Nigel Andrews
85*
Columbus is an absolute charmer whose absolutism is its strength as Kogonada places the modernist buildings of the Indiana town before us and tests the characters’ responses to the artistic verities posed. The framings are uncannily beautiful and the dialogue a wonder.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
3 August 2017 · Justin Chang
85*
Chang describes the film as a sensitively attuned debut that links visual form with emotional depth through characters navigating personal ambitions and family ties amid the city’s modernist buildings. He praises the lead performances and the way architecture charges the interactions with meaning.
Read the full review →L
Little White Lies
8 October 2018 · 3/4/3 · Hannah Strong
80
This absorbing debut explores the relationship between people and spaces in Columbus, Indiana, with strong performances from John Cho and Haley Lu Richardson. The visuals are the real strength, though the slow pace and slightly jarring narrative in the final act hold it back.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
★★★★ · Calum Baker
80
This dreamy, low-key drama makes wonderful use of Columbus's striking modernist buildings through the bond between John Cho and Haley Lu Richardson. Kogonada crafts a pleasant aesthetic while ensuring the characters' humanity shines through.
Read the full review →S
Sight and Sound
5 October 2018 · Ben Nicholson
80*
Kogonada's debut is a meticulously composed coming-of-age story with romantic overtones and intergenerational conflict that recalls Ozu. The film's formal elegance and visual tension around architecture emerge as profoundly affecting elements about family and friendship.
Read the full review →V
Variety
30 January 2017 · festival review · Geoff Berkshire
80*
The review hails the assured, hypnotic debut for treating architecture like music in conversations between the leads and for its gorgeous, meticulously composed filmmaking. It singles out the strong ensemble performances, especially John Cho and Haley Lu Richardson, and the film’s warmth and humanity.
Read the full review →S
Screen Daily
30 January 2017 · festival review
75*
Kogonada brings an idiosyncratic sensibility to this small-town coming-of-age story set against Columbus, Indiana's modernist architecture, creating a nuanced study of people, space and consciousness. Superb ensemble acting and keen intelligence deliver low-key emotional impact despite its rarefied appeal.
Read the full review →N
The New York Times
3 August 2017 · Critic’s Pick · Ben Kenigsberg
70*
The critic praises Kogonada’s confident debut for using the modernist architecture of Columbus, Indiana, as a springboard for exploring generational themes and characters’ connections to place and ideas. It highlights the Ozu-influenced style and strong performances by Haley Lu Richardson and John Cho.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
27 September 2018 · ★★★ · Dave Calhoun
60
Kogonada's first feature offers brooding atmosphere and striking visuals of modernist architecture, evoking Lost in Translation. The story and performances feel less polished than the photography, though it shows promise.
Read the full review →S
The Skinny
13 October 2017 · ★★★★★ · Josh Slater-Williams
100
The review calls the film a masterful, subtle and deeply humanist debut that blends conversational intimacy in the vein of Linklater with Ozu-like family themes, all framed by striking modernist architecture. It singles out Haley Lu Richardson’s revelatory performance as the emotional core conveying passion and curiosity.
Read the full review →P
Paste
7 August 2017 · 8.9 · Andy Crump
90*
Kogonada's feature debut is a quiet, graceful tone poem about family duty and personal uncertainty set against striking modernist architecture. Haley Lu Richardson's towering performance anchors the film and supplies its aching humanity.
Read the full review →P
The Playlist
30 January 2017 · festival review · Jessica Kiang
90*
The critic hails the film as a shimmering, graceful debut overflowing with compassion and natural performances that link modernist architecture appreciation to human connection. She singles out the revelatory work from John Cho and Haley Lu Richardson in drawing an asymmetric yet harmonious friendship.
Read the full review →This restrained debut understands the romantic appeal of intellect and human connection through subtle longing and philosophical conversations. Its seamless blend of meticulous visuals and authentic character work creates an arresting portrait of the Midwest and the need for emotional honesty.
Read the full review →C
Collider
2 August 2017 · B+ · Brian Formo
83
The film is a visually meticulous directorial debut that uses architecture as both setting and metaphor for emotional detachment and personal growth. Haley Lu Richardson delivers a revelatory performance that gives the story its emotional core and elevates the sparse narrative.
Read the full review →E
Eye for Film
8 October 2017 · Amber Wilkinson
80*
The critic finds Kogonada's debut a thoughtful, balanced character study of two people forming a connection in Columbus, Indiana. She singles out the film's careful framing and rhythmic editing that create a soothing poise mirroring the modernist architecture.
Read the full review →The film is a low-key character study in which two strangers bond over modernist architecture in Columbus, Indiana, but it skimps on emotional and narrative details. The critic praises the performances and quiet moments of connection but complains that the minimalist approach leaves characters and relationships underdeveloped.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate