Most critics like Disclosure Day, and the praise clusters in two places. The first is Emily Blunt, named in almost every review as the reason to watch, with Josh O’Connor a frequent second. The second is the direction: the reviews agree that Spielberg still stages a chase with fluid camera movement and clean action, and several read the film as a plea for empathy and curiosity over suspicion. The reservations are about wonder. Variety finds the film leans on decades of familiar alien lore rather than building fresh awe, and the Los Angeles Times goes further, calling it hectic and short on the quiet that made his earlier alien films land. Others mention a plot that works as a flimsy MacGuffin, some hokey lore, a sentimental ending and a runtime that could be tighter. The spread is wide, running from enthusiastic to plainly disappointed, but the enthusiasts outnumber the doubters by a clear margin.
The critic finds that Spielberg's signature sense of awe elevates what is otherwise a somewhat clunky sci-fi thriller. Top marks go to the performances, particularly Emily Blunt's leading turn.
Read the full review →