Most critics enjoy Foreign Correspondent as a brisk espionage thriller and one of Hitchcock’s more assured early Hollywood films. The praise gathers around the set pieces: nearly every review names the Dutch windmill sequence, and the rain-soaked assassination under a sea of umbrellas and the effects-heavy plane crash also draw notice. Several see it as a rehearsal for the chase thrillers he made later, and the cast is consistently approved, with Joel McCrea’s mix of confidence and naivety and George Sanders, Edmund Gwenn and Herbert Marshall in support singled out.
The reservations cluster at the ending. The patriotic finale strikes more than one critic as florid, and Time Out finds it embarrassing today and misses the cruelty and pessimism of Hitchcock’s other work. The spread is narrow, running from warm to enthusiastic, with the Los Angeles Times the lone mixed voice, calling it good rather than great and complaining of too much talk about patriotism.
