The reviews lean firmly positive, with eleven of twelve favourable and several critics placing it near the top of the Bond series. The praise clusters around Connery, who most feel has settled comfortably into the part by this second outing, and around the supporting cast, with Robert Shaw and Lotte Lenya named again and again. The close-quarters fight on the Orient Express is the sequence nearly everyone singles out, alongside the Istanbul location shooting, Terence Young’s direction and John Barry’s score.
The reservations are mild and mostly date from the film’s first release. Variety calls the plot preposterous and notes the female roles are thinly served, while The New Yorker finds the direction often incoherent and enjoys it anyway. The Guardian judges it a shade less fresh than Dr No. Time Out is the lone mixed voice, finding it less memorable than later entries and short on their exotic flamboyance. The spread is narrow.
