With only 5 reviews in so far, most critics praise Peter Weir’s moving account of young Australians going to war, particularly the friendship between its leads. The contrast between the sunlit opening and the trenches draws praise, as does the film’s treatment of comradeship and sacrifice. Reservations concern its historical perspective and pacing: The Telegraph objects to an anti-British bias in the portrayal of command decisions, while Time Out finds the Egypt training section sluggish and its humour crude. The latter is notably cooler than the other reviews, despite admiring the battle photography.
The film follows young Australian soldiers from enlistment through training to the trenches, where their initial sense of adventure gives way to inevitable slaughter. Weir honors the patriotic sacrifice while underscoring the futility, with the unforgettable final freeze-frame singled out as especially powerful.
Read the full review →