Critics’ reviews

Good Time (2017)

20 reviews from 20 publications. Critics’ score 75: 9 positive, 0 mixed, 1 negative.

Back to our review of Good Time

75
Positive
9
Mixed
0
Negative
1

Most critics welcome Good Time as an urgent, unpredictable crime thriller, with praise clustering around Robert Pattinson’s performance as Connie. The reviews find him convincing as a manipulative, desperate criminal, often noting the black comedy and nervous energy of his bad decisions. The Safdies’ restless direction, vivid New York locations and electronic score also draw strong approval. Several critics find feeling in the brothers’ relationship, giving the frantic action a human cost.

The disagreement concerns how much the film offers beyond its immediate thrills. The Telegraph finds the final third weaker, while Collider praises the performances and craft but argues that a plot turn drains the tension. Most assessments remain firmly positive, making The New York Times a marked dissenter: it acknowledges skilful direction and a strong score but finds the film cold, stale and short of substance. Connie’s behaviour is compelling for most critics and alienating for others.

Film Comment
festival review · Amy Taubin
85*

The critic is firmly on the side of the hapless bank robber Connie trying to free his vulnerable brother, calling the film a kinetic trip through New York’s underbelly that proves the Safdies have found their own genre-savvy voice.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
19 November 2017 · Peter Bradshaw
85*

The Safdies deliver an electrifying urban thriller that combines authenticity with accessibility. Pattinson is utterly convincing as the manipulative, volatile Connie.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★★ · Damon Wise
80

A fresh and unpredictable crime story that spins 1980s yuppie-nightmare and 1990s heist tropes into something new, with Pattinson delivering possibly his best performance by mining the role for black comedy as a would-be mastermind who is actually a moron.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
16 November 2017 · ★★★★
80

Pattinson lands his best role yet as a fever-brained small-time crook in this high-stress crime film. The Safdies thrust viewers into the thick of situations with a grungy, electric energy, though the final third lets it down slightly.

Read the full review →
Time Out
25 May 2017 · ★★★★ · Dave Calhoun
80

This cocky, grubby and electric NYC crime thriller features Pattinson on top form as a quick-witted, charismatic chancer whose exploits keep the film moving at a relentless pace. The Safdies’ show-off direction and the depth of supporting characters elevate it beyond a standard thriller.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
10 August 2017 · A.O. Scott
30*

The critic describes the film as ultimately stale, empty and cold despite its crafty direction and strong score. He singles out the protagonist's sliminess and the story's lack of deeper substance for complaint.

Read the full review →
Empire
14 November 2017 · Helen O'Hara

The Safdie brothers deliver an acid-bright, restless chase through New York's grimy corners that stands as one of the year's most compelling thrillers. Pattinson gives a strong, driven performance as the scuzzy but compelling Connie in a gritty, character-driven throwback.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
10 August 2017 · Justin Chang

The critic calls the film a swift, relentless and exhilarating thrill that proves exactly what its title promises. He singles out Robert Pattinson's revelatory, career-best performance for particular praise.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
11 August 2017 · Brian Tallerico

The critic praises the film's anxious, edgy energy reminiscent of 1970s city movies and Robert Pattinson's standout central performance. He singles out Pattinson's conveyance of nervous energy and instinctual bad decisions for particular praise.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
25 May 2017 · festival review

The Safdie brothers unite with Pattinson for an unforgettable ride marked by desperate, grungy velocity and raw performances in a powerfully immersive thriller full of unpredictability. The film crackles with energy and should raise the directors’ profile.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
16 November 2017 · Adam Nayman

The Safdies deliver a frenetic bungled-heist thriller that is morally disorienting yet cinematically expressive, with Pattinson excelling as a low-level hustler whose actions create moral ambiguity without overt judgment. The film’s observational style and visual inventiveness stand out as strengths.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
25 May 2017 · festival review · David Rooney

The critic calls it a riveting race-against-time thriller with a pounding heart. Robert Pattinson's commanding performance and the film's restless visuals and adrenalizing score are singled out for praise.

Read the full review →
Total Film
25 May 2017 · festival review

Robert Pattinson delivers a career-best turn as a criminal in this urgent, gaudy crime-thriller about a botched heist and escalating night of mayhem. The Safdies craft a poetically pulpy, sweaty ode to 70s crime films with vivid performances and a striking electro score.

Read the full review →
Variety
25 May 2017 · festival review · Guy Lodge

The critic highlights the film's nervy, vivid heist thriller qualities and Robert Pattinson's career-peak performance. He singles out the blend of gutter realism with tight genre mechanics for praise.

Read the full review →
Vulture
8 August 2017 · festival review

The review describes a propulsive thriller centered on a humane, destructive brotherly love. Pattinson's intense, empathetic performance as Connie is highlighted as some of his best work.

Read the full review →
The Ringer
8 August 2017 · K. Austin Collins
90*

The critic calls it an instant classic New York City movie and the Safdie brothers' best film yet, highlighting its frenetic ode to the city's underbelly and Pattinson's ferocious, unpredictable performance as Connie. It singles out the film's thrilling, morally complex portrayal of manipulation and inequity, rooted in a vivid, chaotic present-day New York without didactic reminders of its timeliness.

Read the full review →
The Skinny
5 May 2022 · ★★★★ · Joseph Walsh
80

Robert Pattinson gives a blistering, accomplished performance as the desperate low-level criminal Connie in this breathless heist movie that proves the Safdie brothers’ finest work so far, with a frantic ride centered on the brothers’ relationship and strong support from the score and cinematography.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
10 August 2017 · Sam Fragoso
80*

The Safdie brothers deliver a taut, tough tale of one sibling doing everything possible to bail out the other after a botched bank robbery. The critic singles out Robert Pattinson’s manic, adrenalized performance and the authentic, textured depiction of Queens as the film’s standout elements.

Read the full review →
Collider
10 August 2017 · B- · Gregory Ellwood
70

The critic praises the strong performances, especially Pattinson's nuanced take on an unsympathetic character, along with the memorable electronic score and striking visuals from cinematographer Sean Price Williams. However, the gritty thriller ultimately fails to fully add up, with a twist that saps tension and leaves the viewer disengaged from the protagonist's desperate actions.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
25 May 2017 · B+/A- · Jessica Kiang

The critic hails the film's electric, propulsive energy and Robert Pattinson's commanding lead performance. They single out the sincere, authentic portrayal of the brothers' relationship alongside the seamless blend of genre thrills with arthouse sensibilities.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate