Critics’ reviews

Hell or High Water (2016)

28 reviews from 28 publications. Critics’ score 78: 19 positive, 1 mixed, 1 negative.

Back to our review of Hell or High Water

78
Positive
19
Mixed
1
Negative
1

Most critics welcome Hell or High Water as a tense, dryly funny crime film whose familiar bank robberies and pursuit gain weight from the poverty of its West Texas setting. Praise centres on Taylor Sheridan’s dialogue, David Mackenzie’s assured pacing and a cast that makes the family loyalties and professional partnerships convincing. Jeff Bridges draws the most consistent attention for his weary, expressive Ranger, while Chris Pine earns praise for giving the brothers’ story emotional weight.

The disagreement concerns how much the film adds to its familiar material. Most reviews find its economic pressures persuasive and its characters nuanced; a small minority find the social commentary thin or the plotting too arranged. Time Out enjoys the old-fashioned pleasures but hears little new. The New Yorker is the sharp dissenter, finding the writing contrived and lifeless, though it shares the broader admiration for Bridges. The spread is wide, but approval predominates.

The AV Club
11 August 2016 · A- · A.A. Dowd
90

The film makes one fall in love again with dialogue through its plainspoken wit and flavorful conversation. It delivers a skillful, offbeat neo-Western heist with relaxed yet urgent execution and strong character work.

Read the full review →
Vulture
11 August 2016
90*

It is a rare humanist Western where finality is the true villain, offering broad scale and deep feeling in a haunting neo-Western with a terrible clarity and one of the greatest final scenes of any Western.

Read the full review →
Empire
5 September 2016 · Jimi Famurewa
80*

The critic praises the film as a taut, tense neo-Western that effectively blends old and new elements in its depiction of Texan cops and robbers. Bridges' performance is highlighted as a standout, bringing weary vulnerability to his role.

Read the full review →
Financial Times
29 December 2016 · Raphael Abraham
80*

David Mackenzie’s powerful neo-Western paints a vivid portrait of disenfranchised America. The script is sharply sardonic and the overall mood is sober and elegiac.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
7 September 2016 · 3/4/4 · Manuela Lazic
80

Jeff Bridges gives his best performance in years in this timely crime caper from David Mackenzie. The critic praises the realistic modern Texas setting marked by poverty, the sarcastic humour from civilians and authorities, and the subversion of heist conventions in favour of a broader critique of capitalism.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★★ · Damon Wise
80

British director David Mackenzie masters modern Americana like a native with this rustic noir that invokes the spirit of the Coen brothers. The critic praises the familiar story being very well told, with snappy dialogue, three top-notch performances and a great dustbowl soundtrack.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
9 August 2016
80*

Sheridan's screenplay twists genre conventions while the stark atmosphere and intimate character focus keep the action on a muted emotional keel, building to a messy, bloody conclusion that ruptures a delicate social ecosystem.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
8 September 2016 · ★★★★ · Tim Robey
80

Give Mackenzie this strong script and his game is raised, delivering straight-down-the-highway momentum, interesting stakes, and textured character work. It is a chase movie with a moral conscience that is neither obvious nor one-sided.

Read the full review →
The Times
11 September 2016 · ★★★★ · Edward Porter
80

Mackenzie embraces the desolate Texas setting with relish and has a good cast. Taylor Sheridan’s script makes good on the potential with an interesting motive for the bank jobs.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
9 September 2016 · Charlotte O'Sullivan
75*

The review finds the film engaging despite a conventional plot, crediting strong characterizations and sly direction for its appeal. Performances by Bridges and Pine are singled out as outstanding and Oscar-worthy.

Read the full review →
Film Comment
25 August 2016 · Michael Sragow
70*

The critic finds Jeff Bridges the standout delight in an otherwise compromised story, praising his effortless portrayal of the Texas Ranger. He notes the director's work is handsome and tactful but not deeply probing.

Read the full review →
Time Out
11 August 2016 · ★★★ · Tom Huddleston
60

This dusty Texas crime story is well-worn but its simple pleasures hold up in an old-fashioned yet enjoyable heist thriller that adds a dash of 21st-century politics. The critic singles out the memorable moments, most involving Jeff Bridges hurling insults, while noting not a great deal new to say.

Read the full review →
The New Yorker
19 August 2016 · Richard Brody
30*

The critic sees the film as flat and schematic, driven by a screenwriter’s keyboard rather than lived-in action or dialogue, with the main respite being Jeff Bridges’s expressive performance. It faults the contrived family-history elements and overall lack of vitality despite strong casting.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
10 August 2016 · Glenn Whipp

The critic calls it a gripping heist drama attuned to outsider politics, with brothers robbing banks to settle a score while evoking empathy for their motives amid West Texas desolation. It singles out the screenplay’s balance of thriller, character study, and social commentary, plus the director’s brisk pacing.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
16 May 2016 · festival review

David Mackenzie delivers his most commercially appealing and one of his most fully achieved films yet, working from an expertly honed screenplay. The critic singles out the intertwining of two mismatched buddy relationships, especially the one between the rangers played by Jeff Bridges and Gil Birmingham, and the vivid support casting and dialogue.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
13 September 2016 · Trevor Johnson

Hard times make hard desperados in David Mackenzie's sage, post-recessionary Texan crime thriller. The critic praises the thorough investment in sense of place and the strong performances, especially Jeff Bridges' masterly late-period character study and the world-weary bond between the siblings.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
16 May 2016 · festival review

The critic praises this heavyweight, cynical thriller as a heist picture with satirical edge and a gloomy reverie about the Texan plain. Mackenzie’s direction and the cast deliver punch and maturity.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
16 May 2016 · festival review · David Rooney

The film is a soulful outlaw tale with a socioeconomic perspective and a rich sense of place. It features strong performances from the leads in a modern Western thriller that imbues familiar types with humanity.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
11 August 2016 · Critic’s Pick · Jeannette Catsoulis

The critic finds it an easygoing thriller set in a roasted West Texas landscape where the bank-robbing brothers’ plan unfolds gradually amid nonchalant characters. The film is praised for its unhurried cops-and-robbers tale that reveals the thieves’ smarter motives over time.

Read the full review →
Variety
16 May 2016 · festival review · Owen Gleiberman

The critic hails it as a thrillingly good, crackerjack drama of crime, fear, and brotherly love set in an authentic sun-roasted West Texas, merging crime-spree noir with family history. It praises the brilliant lead performances, especially Chris Pine’s breakthrough, and the director’s gripping independent production.

Read the full review →
Den of Geek
11 August 2016 · ★★★★★ · Don Kaye
100

The critic calls it one of the best films of the year, a tense modern-day Western full of desperation and strong performances from the leads. He highlights the rich socio-economic backdrop and the nuanced characters caught between family loyalty and systemic pressures.

Read the full review →
Collider
11 August 2016 · A- · Brian Formo
90

The critic calls it one of the best films of the year, praising its thoughtful screenplay and career-high performances from the leads. They single out the believable bond between the brothers for adding meaningful history to the script.

Read the full review →
Deadline
10 August 2016 · Pete Hammond
85*

The critic calls the film a must-see smart and intelligent thriller that mixes entertainment with something to think about. He singles out the relevant contemporary issues raised alongside strong performances, especially from Chris Pine.

Read the full review →
Consequence
10 August 2016
80*

The critic praises it as a thrilling, tense, and weirdly funny heist film with a tight script that builds a rich milieu and mines genuine laughs from local culture and practicalities. They single out the score and the sense of isolation for enhancing the dread and character depth.

Read the full review →
HeyUGuys
16 May 2016 · ★★★★ · Jo-Ann Titmarsh
80

The critic finds the film a solid cops-and-robbers tale that stays true to traditional storytelling while depicting the disenfranchised with nuance. Strong performances from the leads, particularly Jeff Bridges, are highlighted alongside the script's clear-eyed view of consequences.

Read the full review →
The Skinny
2 September 2016 · ★★★★ · Josh Slater-Williams
80

The critic praises the screenplay for adding depth and social commentary beyond a simple genre exercise, along with the vivid Texas landscapes and Chris Pine's standout performance. He deems it one of the finest recent American crime films.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
11 August 2016 · Robert Abele
80*

The critic finds it a witty and surprisingly wise slice of Lone Star unlawfulness with righteous criminality and pokey humor. He singles out Jeff Bridges' master-class performance as the veteran Ranger alongside the strong ensemble and craftsman-like direction.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
11 August 2016 · B · Nikola Grozdanovic
77

The review praises the film's entertaining caper elements, Coens-like colorful characters, and balance of humor with deeper themes of generational loss and modern America. Strong side performances and Bridges' standout work are singled out for making it a personality-driven ride.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate