Most critics like Idiocracy. The praise clusters on the satire: Mike Judge’s picture of an America dumbed down by advertising, junk television and contempt for thinking is called merciless, pitch-black and, by the reviews written a decade or more after release, accurate. Several single out the visual gags and the naming of real brands. Luke Wilson’s everyman draws warm words from Empire, and Terry Crews’s President Camacho is picked out by Consequence among the comic performances.
The reservations are about everything except the ideas. Variety finds the plot and scenes weaker than the concept; Slant calls the execution scattershot and compares it to a good episode of Futurama rather than a classic; Radio Times thinks the hero too blank to care about. The Guardian blames studio interference for that. Two later pieces add that the film’s jokes about class and intelligence have aged badly. The spread is narrow: three mixed notices, no hostile ones.
