Critics’ reviews

Idiocracy (2006)

11 reviews from 11 publications. Critics’ score 72: 8 positive, 3 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of Idiocracy

72
Positive
8
Mixed
3
Negative
0

Most critics like Idiocracy. The praise clusters on the satire: Mike Judge’s picture of an America dumbed down by advertising, junk television and contempt for thinking is called merciless, pitch-black and, by the reviews written a decade or more after release, accurate. Several single out the visual gags and the naming of real brands. Luke Wilson’s everyman draws warm words from Empire, and Terry Crews’s President Camacho is picked out by Consequence among the comic performances.

The reservations are about everything except the ideas. Variety finds the plot and scenes weaker than the concept; Slant calls the execution scattershot and compares it to a good episode of Futurama rather than a classic; Radio Times thinks the hero too blank to care about. The Guardian blames studio interference for that. Two later pieces add that the film’s jokes about class and intelligence have aged badly. The spread is narrow: three mixed notices, no hostile ones.

The AV Club
6 September 2006 · A- · Nathan Rabin
90

The critic finds the film a smartly lowbrow and unrepentant satire that literalizes societal devolution into stupidity and anti-intellectualism. It singles out the visual gags and commentary on crass consumerism and advertising for particular praise.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
4 September 2006 · Carina Chocano
80*

The critic praises Judge's merciless satire on a dumbed-down future, highlighting its spot-on skewering of corporations, junk culture, and systems like healthcare. She notes the plot is silly but the nightmarish extrapolation makes it a cathartic delight.

Read the full review →
Empire
· Nick de Semlyen
70*

The critic praises the film's sharp satiric high-concept about a dumbed-down future and its gutsy comedy with something to say, noting Luke Wilson's sweet central performance and the funny execution despite its slight length.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
8 September 2006 · John Patterson
70*

The critic finds the film a splenetic, pitch-black satire with venomous anti-corporate bite that names real brands and skewers consumerism, TV and anti-intellectualism. While not a masterpiece due to studio interference, it is endlessly funny with strong cult-hit potential.

Read the full review →
The Times
9 December 2009 · Kevin Maher
70*

The critic presents the film as a scathing political satire of a dystopian, moronic future America undone by anti-intellectualism and vulgarity, reduced to slogans and reality TV. It serves as an ominous portrait of contemporary political trends like those associated with Sarah Palin.

Read the full review →
Variety
1 September 2006 · Robert Koehler
65*

Koehler finds it a timely satire on a moronic future, strong on big ideas and corporate critique but weaker on plot and individual scenes; praises the visual gags and rebellious spirit despite flaws.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★ · Lucy Barrick
60

Judge takes the dumbing-down of the USA to its logical extreme in a nightmarish vision of a lowest-common-denominator future that is hilarious and depressingly believable. Although the everyman protagonist is too much of a blank slate to care about, the gaudy visuals and cynical gags compensate.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
8 January 2007 · Fernando F. Croce
60*

The review deems the film more like a solid episode of Futurama than the subversive classic its troubled release suggested, though it credits the nervy concept and cultural ire. It singles out the scattershot execution and lack of rhythm as drawbacks while noting the bracing satire of ignorance and corporate greed.

Read the full review →
Den of Geek
5 February 2019 · Chris Longo
80*

The critic views Idiocracy as a prescient cult classic whose satire on societal dumbing down and corporatization feels eerily relevant today. They single out its accurate predictions about politics and consumer culture for praise, while noting some criticism regarding classist undertones.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
26 September 2012 · Jeff Robson
80*

The critic praises Mike Judge's satire for its accurate predictions about mass culture, fame, and politics becoming entertainment, while noting the gleeful skewering of crass commercialism alongside affection for the flawed characters. Strong comic performances and laugh-out-loud set pieces are highlighted as making it well worth seeking out or rediscovering, though it runs out of steam in places.

Read the full review →
Consequence
3 September 2016 · Clint Worthington
75*

The critic views the 10-year retrospective on Mike Judge's cult satire as both self-satisfied and eerily prescient, praising its broad world-building, comedic performances (especially Terry Crews as President Camacho), and low-budget realization of a dystopian future while critiquing how some class and intelligence themes have aged poorly or been misinterpreted.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate