
Most critics respond warmly to Isle of Dogs, with praise concentrated on its stop-motion animation and meticulous production design. The expressive dogs, densely detailed rubbish-island setting and dry visual humour repeatedly stand out, while several reviews find real tenderness in the central boy-and-dog story. Anderson’s precise staging is widely seen as well suited to animation, and the film’s bleakness gives its canine adventure an edge beyond the expected charm.
Reservations centre on a crowded, sometimes meandering plot and the handling of Japanese culture and human characters. The Los Angeles Times admires the miniature craft but finds the cultural treatment troubling; other broadly favourable reviews also raise concerns. The spread is mostly positive, though the Evening Standard is a clear dissenter, finding that the elaborate story struggles to sustain attention or sympathy. Even among admirers, the emotional impact and the busier later passages attract less consistent praise than the animation.
S
Sight and Sound
28 March 2018 · Kim Newman
90*
The critic praises the film's delightful detail, sympathy for its furry leads, and labor of love quality, highlighting a standout speech by Chief as perfectly written and staged.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
29 March 2018 · Peter Bradshaw
90*
Anderson delivers another distinctive, formally brilliant stop-motion film set in a dystopian future Japan, crammed with visual invention and hyper-intelligent gags. The critic singles out the expressive clarity of the dogs' movements and the bleak garbage-island landscape for particular praise.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
15 February 2018 · festival review · David Rooney
90*
The review finds Wes Anderson's stop-motion film a thoroughly captivating and wildly distinctive tale of a boy's quest to rescue his dog amid a canine quarantine scheme. It singles out the vibrantly inventive visuals, meticulous production design, and chapter-structured narrative for particular praise.
Read the full review →The review calls the film sui generis and the most lyrically disjunctive movie ever made, one that harmonizes its disparate elements into a magical whole. It singles out the breathtaking stop-motion mise-en-scène and visual perfection for praise while noting the witty screenplay.
Read the full review →E
Empire
23 February 2018 · Nick de Semlyen
80*
Anderson makes amends for past on-screen dog deaths with a joyous, visually splendid and entrancing stop-motion film full of whimsy, pathos and inventive details, though the charm falters slightly in the third act with some freneticism and uneven voice cast impact.
Read the full review →F
Film Comment
1 March 2018 · Jonathan Romney
80*
The critic praises the film's visual richness, inventive mix of animation styles, and witty execution while acknowledging debates over its portrayal of Japanese culture.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
6 March 2018 · ★★★★ · Andrew Collins
80
Praises it as wholly, idiosyncratically unique, a technical and artistic marvel with affectionate homages, though notes potential issues with cultural aspects and themes.
Read the full review →i
The i Paper
22 February 2018 · ★★★★ · Matthew Turner
80
A captivating return to stop-motion with a bleak yet inventive dystopian Japan tale full of astounding detail, strong emotion, laugh-out-loud gags and immersive production design; original, topical and a tasty treat for fans.
Read the full review →T
The Telegraph
29 March 2018 · ★★★★
80
Anderson upends expectations of a cute canine tale with a weird, dark vision of survival on a trash island that includes graphic details like a kidney transplant. The critic praises the remarkable beauty and sober delight in the creatures' struggle while noting it exits Anderson's usual comfort zone.
Read the full review →N
The New Yorker
16 March 2018 · Anthony Lane
70*
The critic finds the stop-motion animation a perfect fit for Anderson's precise style and praises the tiny details and world-building, but notes the plot's density and questions the inclusion of a Western savior character.
Read the full review →Anderson's stop-motion animation delivers talking dogs and cute scenarios but is also bleak and unsettling, with a tone of existential despair created through painful silences and bursts of savagery. The critic notes the wry humour and droll gags but emphasizes that the film ultimately bites with its dark heart.
Read the full review →V
Variety
15 February 2018 · Critic's Pick · Guy Lodge
70*
The critic praises the richly imagined, drily witty canine adventure and its world-building, highlighting the tactile animation of the dogs and Anderson's Japanophilia, while noting some narrative meandering.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
21 March 2018 · Justin Chang
60*
The review calls the film a triumph of invention and micro-detail in its stop-motion craft and dog characters, while criticizing the handling of Japanese human characters and cultural sensitivity issues.
Read the full review →E
Evening Standard
16 February 2018 · festival review · Rick Roddick
40*
The film struggles to maintain sympathy or hold attention with its stop-motion dogs and meandering plot through Anderson's imagination; while there are some lovely touches like the barking language conceit and detailed world, the story is too complex for kids and delivers more bark than bite.
Read the full review →S
The Skinny
16 February 2018 · ★★★★★ · Jamie Dunn
100
The critic highlights the gorgeous stop-motion trash-island setting, rambunctious storytelling, and Anderson's growing political edge, calling it his most wildly imaginative work.
Read the full review →D
Deadline
20 March 2018 · Pete Hammond
90*
The review calls it a charming, bizarre, and weird stop-motion film with a dense and complex storyline. It praises the first-rate production design, tech credits, and Alexandre Desplat's Asian-flavored score, describing the whole as more fun than you can imagine.
Read the full review →C
Collider
22 March 2018 · B+ · Matt Goldberg
83
The critic finds it another winner from Anderson, praising the dog-and-boy story and political elements though not as stirring as some previous films.
Read the full review →P
The Playlist
15 February 2018 · B+ · Jessica Kiang
83
The film is a visually dazzling stop-motion miracle with expressive puppets, charming imagery, puns and a potent political undercurrent. The narrative can feel messy and undisciplined, but the joyous commitment to Japanese aesthetics is self-justifying.
Read the full review →H
HeyUGuys
29 March 2018 · ★★★★ · Scott Davis
80
The stop-motion design and visuals are immaculate and sumptuous throughout. The story mixes humor, warmth and seriousness effectively, bolstered by outstanding vocal performances, especially from Bryan Cranston.
Read the full review →R
The Ringer
22 March 2018 · K. Austin Collins
80*
Praises the tactile stop-motion animation and central boy-and-dogs story while noting cultural crosscurrents and bittersweet tone.
Read the full review →D
Den of Geek
29 March 2018 · 4 out of 5 · Mark Harrison
70*
The critic calls it a bewitchingly weird and imaginative animated drama with striking design and underlying sincerity, landing between Kurosawa and a boys' adventure.
Read the full review →W
The Wrap
22 March 2018 · Robert Abele
70*
The critic finds the film a mostly enjoyable but overstuffed adventure with stunning visuals and political undertones. It praises the meticulous design, witty elements, and narrative layering while noting concerns about cultural appropriation and the lack of subtitles for Japanese characters.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate