Critics’ reviews

Journey to Italy (1954)

11 reviews from 11 publications. Critics’ score 78: 8 positive, 2 mixed, 1 negative.

Back to our review of Journey to Italy

78
Positive
8
Mixed
2
Negative
1

Most critics respond warmly to Journey to Italy, praising its close attention to a strained marriage and the way the Italian surroundings unsettle the couple. The strongest notices find emotional depth in its understated approach, with location shooting and the encounters with ancient places giving private unhappiness a wider significance. Praise also clusters around its willingness to depart from conventional storytelling, which several critics regard as central to its lasting influence.

The spread is nevertheless wide, with pace and dramatic construction dividing opinion more than the subject itself. Empire recognises the film’s influence but warns that its deliberate shortage of pace and drama can test patience. Variety finds brilliant passages alongside ordinary stretches and rough execution. These reservations remain a minority view: most reviews treat the quietness and loose narrative as strengths, finding the couple’s emotional unease absorbing rather than insufficiently eventful.

Time Out
3 May 2013 · ★★★★★ · Trevor Johnston
100

The critic hails its classic status and profound, heady affirmation of vulnerable togetherness in the face of time and mortality. He singles out the ancient, passionate Italian landscape and customs for gradually making their mark on the estranged couple.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
8 May 2013 · Geoff Andrew
90*

The critic calls it a very, very great film and a landmark masterpiece that feels timeless. He singles out its nuanced examination of the inner lives and emotional complexities of its upper-middle-class characters as it moves beyond neorealism.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
29 April 2013 · Fernando F. Croce
90*

The critic calls the film a 1954 masterpiece that unfolds as both a thorny narrative and a personal documentary, capturing the emotional unease of a disintegrating marriage that mirrors the real-life Rossellini-Bergman relationship. The Pompeii excavation scene and the transcendent finale amid a religious procession are singled out as moments where the cosmic and existential dimensions elevate the understated style into an overwhelming vision of hope and self-awareness.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
9 May 2013 · Peter Bradshaw
90*

The restored re-release is a mysterious, gripping and moving study of a troubled English couple whose Italian trip exposes the cracks in their marriage. The critic singles out the electrifying Pompeii sequence for particular praise as evidence of the film's real greatness.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
30 April 2013 · Critic’s Pick · A.O. Scott
90*

The critic hails the film as a masterpiece overlooked upon its initial release, praising its atmospheric depiction of a strained marriage amid postwar Italy and its anticipation of modernist cinema.

Read the full review →
The New Yorker
19 April 2013 · Richard Brody
85*

The critic describes it as a quietly revolutionary work that transforms romantic melodrama into intellectual adventure through location shooting and attention to cultural settings, singling out the Pompeii sequence for its existential resonance.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
10 May 2013
80*

The critic calls Rossellini's 1954 masterwork a classic that affirms relationships, noting its parallels to the director's own life with Ingrid Bergman. The review highlights the story of a crumbling marriage tested during a trip to sell property in Naples.

Read the full review →
Empire
1 January 2013 · Patrick Peters
60*

The review describes the film as a minor classic reclaimed after initial dismissal, noting its influence on the French New Wave and its focus on a troubled couple's holiday. It praises the contrast in styles but notes the deliberate lack of pace and drama may challenge viewers.

Read the full review →
Variety
31 December 1953 · Variety Staff
50*

The review notes the story of a couple nearing divorce who warm to Italy but finds the film uneven overall, with brilliant moments alternating with so-so stretches and some rough execution.

Read the full review →
The Times
27 January 2023 · ★★★★☆ · Ed Potton
30*

This classic film of the week shows a stiff English marriage imploding during a Naples trip, with Bergman as a bundle of neuroses and a rising sense of dread. The Pompeii petrified-couple scene is highlighted as making the symbolism unbearable, though the ending remains uncertain.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
10 May 2004 · ★★★★★ · Caro Ness
100

The film is a portrait of a marriage in crisis set against the backdrop of Naples. The critic singles out the exquisite cinematography and the director's daring challenge to traditional narrative conventions for particular praise.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate