Kes is admired almost without exception. Thirteen of fourteen reviews are positive, and the praise gathers in the same places: David Bradley’s performance as Billy, the bullied boy who trains a kestrel, and Loach’s handling of a cast of non-professionals, which most critics credit for the film’s documentary feel. The scenes of boy and bird on the moors are singled out repeatedly, as is Chris Menges’ photography of the Yorkshire town and its interiors, which The Times says the restoration shows to advantage. Several reviewers also find more humour and warmth than the subject suggests.
The spread is narrow and the reservations small. Variety and Sight and Sound admire the cast but call the style rough, and the latter finds the film thinner in autobiographical detail than comparable work. The one mixed notice is The New York Times, which calls the film honourable and decent but never quite as interesting as the people in it, while conceding Loach’s gift with actors.
