Most critics respond warmly to Late Fame, praising its tenderness towards artistic ambition, self-delusion and the wish to be recognised. Willem Dafoe’s restrained performance as a rediscovered poet draws the most consistent praise, while Greta Lee’s theatrical energy provides a contrast that several reviews particularly enjoy. Kent Jones’s gentle, observant direction also wins approval for finding humour in New York’s literary circles without treating the people in them with contempt.
The main disagreement concerns whether that gentleness leaves the drama short of bite. Some otherwise favourable reviews note narrative stumbles, thinly drawn young artists or insufficient tension; Time Out finds the film reluctant to commit to its tragic, comic or feel-good possibilities. The spread extends from strong enthusiasm to outright disappointment: Little White Lies finds the dialogue unilluminating and the nostalgia grating, rejecting the fondness that most critics regard as a strength.
N
The New Yorker
7 August 2026 · Justin Chang
85*
The critic finds the drama exquisitely wry and melancholic, with Jones turning characters’ foibles and pretensions into acts of tenderness. He singles out Dafoe’s finest performance in years for its trek from bliss to disillusionment and odd contentment.
Read the full review →A
The AV Club
4 August 2026 · B+ · Tim Grierson
83
The critic finds it a tender, bittersweet drama led by Dafoe's tender performance, praising its exploration of self-delusion, generational divides, and the desire for recognition, though noting some narrative stumbles.
Read the full review →E
Empire
4 September 2026 · Emily Maskell
80*
The critic praises the film as a low-key but moving intergenerational portrait of ambitious writers in contemporary New York. Dafoe’s grounded performance is highlighted as a compelling treat that clashes effectively with Greta Lee’s theatricality.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
1 September 2026 · ★★★★ · Tom Dawson
80
This observant character study, transposed to contemporary New York, treats its characters with compassion and features impressive performances, especially from Willem Dafoe as the rediscovered poet. It notes the amusing pretensions of the young aesthetes without dismissing their nostalgia.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
2 September 2026 · Peter Bradshaw
80*
The critic praises this elegant, smart and literate adaptation as a tonic with marvellous tenderness and generosity, highlighting Willem Dafoe’s intelligent and self-possessed performance as the ageing poet.
Read the full review →V
Variety
30 August 2025 · festival review · Owen Gleiberman
80*
The critic finds the film lyrical and enchanting, praising Jones’s naturalistic style driven by curiosity that reveals the humanity of everyone onscreen. He singles out Dafoe’s performance as a slowly unfolding wildflower that conveys buried yearning and resilience.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
14 August 2026 · Gary Goldstein
75*
The critic calls the film often first-rate for its wisdom and depth on aging, dashed dreams, and the magic of rediscovery, plus a deliciously ironic final twist. He singles out the superb cast managed with aplomb and the cinematographer’s evocative capture of lower Manhattan.
Read the full review →O
The Observer
2 September 2026 · Wendy Ide
75*
The review calls the film a supremely elegant adaptation and character study that captures the faded soul of New York’s art scene, praising the nuanced performances especially from Willem Dafoe and Greta Lee.
Read the full review →F
Financial Times
3 September 2026 · Danny Leigh
70*
The critic finds the film funny and genial with a cool astringency, boosted by strong performances from Willem Dafoe and Greta Lee, noting its wry take on fleeting moments and talent.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
15 August 2026 · ★★★ · Anna Smith
60
The film toys with tragic, comic and feel-good modes but declines to commit fully, delivering an unsentimental story anchored by Willem Dafoe’s lived-in performance. It drifts toward a graceful conclusion while studying its pretentious characters largely without judgment.
Read the full review →L
Little White Lies
1 September 2025 · festival review · Hannah Strong
35*
Kent Jones’ comedy about a rediscovered poet talks a lot but doesn’t say anything new or compelling. It criticizes the script’s lack of bite compared to May December and finds the nostalgic downtown New York gaze grating and underdeveloped, especially in its treatment of characters.
Read the full review →F
Film Comment
20 October 2025 · festival review · Molly Haskell
The critic highlights Willem Dafoe's thoughtful, heartfelt performance at the center of this melancholy adaptation of an Arthur Schnitzler novella. It praises the film's sharp observations on bohemian poseurs and its cathartic ending.
Read the full review →I
IndieWire
30 August 2025 · festival review · Vikram Murthi
The critic describes it as a perceptive urban drama, noting how the update of the novella allows for an insightful look at a former poet falling in with a young crowd and the dynamics that ensue.
Read the full review →S
Screen Daily
30 August 2025 · festival review
Kent Jones’s second feature is a perceptive, lightfooted drama examining the thin line between creative aspiration and pretentious poseurdom, with strong turns from Willem Dafoe and especially Greta Lee, who steals scenes as the eccentric actress Gloria.
Read the full review →S
Sight and Sound
27 August 2026
Kent Jones’s playful drama pokes gentle fun at New York literary circles old and new in a poetic meditation on the transience of fame. It highlights Dafoe’s perfect performance and the film’s compassionate, generous view of its anachronistic characters.
Read the full review →S
Slant Magazine
7 September 2025 · festival review · Marshall Shaffer
The critic finds the film amiable but notes it pulls its punches, praising Dafoe's graceful performance and the sincere direction while criticizing the limited perspective on characters and lack of stronger dramatic tension.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
30 August 2025 · festival review · Sheri Linden
The critic calls the film understated and sharp, praising Dafoe's conflicted yet perfect performance as the rediscovered poet and the screenplay's exploration of notoriety and identity through graceful notes and character interactions.
Read the full review →N
The New York Times
6 August 2026 · Critic’s Pick · Alissa Wilkinson
The critic praises the film's wise and fond understanding of why some people want to become artists without making much art and why others quit. She singles out Jones’s light, confident, naturalistic direction and grasp of the Greenwich Village milieu.
Read the full review →The critic lauds Dafoe and Lee's performances and the enchanting premise but notes the film stumbles with cartoonish treatment of the young artists and feels less assured overall.
Read the full review →P
The Playlist
13 August 2026 · A- · Rodrigo Perez
90
The film is a wry, clever, and thoughtful low-key portrait of modest fame and artistic validation. It singles out Willem Dafoe's delicate performance and the sly screenplay's handling of ego, class, and pretension in contemporary New York.
Read the full review →D
Deadline
3 August 2026 · Pete Hammond
85*
The critic calls it a gem about discovery and rediscovery, praising the superb performances of Willem Dafoe and Greta Lee along with the witty, biting screenplay that treats its characters with humanity and grace rather than satire.
Read the full review →E
Eye for Film
30 September 2025 · festival review · Anne-Katrin Titze
80*
Burch and Jones update the story to the present without falling into cliché, giving Dafoe and especially Greta Lee opportunities to show new sides of their acting. Greta Lee's performance of the Brecht/Weill song forms the disquieting core of this precise, layered film.
Read the full review →W
The Wrap
1 September 2025 · festival review
75*
The review portrays it as a loving low-key farce that skewers and sympathizes with its characters in equal measure, highlighting Willem Dafoe's nuanced performance and the director's layered, non-cynical approach to themes of artistic legacy and class.
Read the full review →N
NME
3 September 2026 · Jordan Bassett
The critic describes the film as poignant but slightly unsatisfying, an elegy for old New York that fails to fully land its themes. Willem Dafoe's spellbinding performance as the rediscovered poet is singled out for strong praise.
Read the full review →P
Paste
27 September 2025 · 5.8 · Jesse Hassenger
The film is a predictable, mild satire of New York artistic circles that lacks sharp danger or deep character development, feeling like a lesser late-period Woody Allen dramedy. Dafoe's lead performance is convincingly modest and central, but even he cannot fully overcome the broad arcs and uneven supporting elements.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate