Most critics are won over, and they largely agree on why. The praise clusters on David Dastmalchian as the failing chat-show host, described again and again as the film’s anchor, and on the recreation of a 1977 late-night broadcast, from the sets and sound to the rhythm of a live studio. The found-footage conceit is widely judged fresh, with several reviews reaching for Ghostwatch and The Exorcist as reference points. Reservations are consistent too. The final act, where the broadcast tips into chaos, is where enthusiasm cools, with Vulture finding it loses steam and Deadline judging the ending carries excess baggage. The Guardian is cooler than the rest, arguing the film captures the strained feel of studio television without ever becoming disturbing. Sight and Sound goes further, saying the concept is undermined when the film stops obeying its own formal rules. The spread is narrow: ten positive, one mixed, none hostile.
A
The AV Club
21 March 2024 · A · Matthew Jackson
95
The high-concept horror film succeeds as a forbidden, immersive 1970s nightmare anchored by Dastmalchian’s magnetic performance. Jackson singles out the meticulous production design, sound design, and escalating tension as making it one of the year’s best horror films.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
★★★★ · Alan Jones
80
A found-footage frightener that freshens demonic possession clichés with jet black humour and superb effects in a 1970s chat show setting, briskly entertaining and unnerving.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
14 March 2024 · ★★★★ · Phil de Semlyen
80
Praises it as a diabolically brilliant found-footage horror, like Alan Partridge by way of The Exorcist, with clever ideas and creepy atmosphere.
Read the full review →David Dastmalchian shines in this sophisticated horror movie that stands out for its clever premise and execution.
Read the full review →V
Vulture
21 March 2024 · Bilge Ebiri
70*
Dastmalchian delivers a star-making turn as a slick yet uncertain late-night host in this inventive horror film set during a single 1977 broadcast. Ebiri praises the actor’s layered performance and the film’s structural conceit but notes it loses steam in the final act.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
18 March 2024 · ★★★
60
The directors have fun sending up TV conventions as a failing host attempts to revive his career by communing with a demon supposedly possessing a teenage girl. The film capably bottles the strained ersatzness of studio television but does not cut through to anything genuinely disturbing.
Read the full review →E
Empire
22 March 2024 · Helen O'Hara
The critic finds this found-footage horror a chilling success that blends Network and The Exorcist, focusing on the venality of fame-seeking in late-night TV. Praise goes to the tension-building and strong central performance by David Dastmalchian.
Read the full review →I
IndieWire
19 March 2024 · David Ehrlich
The film is a clever found-footage satire in which a desperate 1970s talk-show host invites the supernatural onto live TV. Ehrlich praises David Dastmalchian’s leading performance while highlighting the film’s effective recreation of period television.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
21 March 2024 · Amy Nicholson
The critic describes the film as a sly, aw-shucksy chiller that cleverly reminds viewers the entertainment business was built on hocus-pocus, centering on a talk show host whose desperate ratings grab unleashes supernatural chaos on Halloween 1977. She highlights the lead performance and period satire as strengths.
Read the full review →S
Screen Daily
31 July 2023 · festival review
Inventive and entertaining blend of found footage and possession in a 70s talk show format, with excellent performance by Dastmalchian; distinctive despite Ghostwatch comparisons.
Read the full review →S
Sight and Sound
25 March 2024
The critic finds the ingenious concept of a demonic live TV broadcast undermined by failure to stick to its formal rules, resulting in an underwhelming film despite strong performances and production.
Read the full review →S
Slant Magazine
18 March 2024 · #### · Ross McIndoe
The Cairnes brothers deliver a devilishly fun horror satire by transplanting occult tropes into a 1970s talk-show format. McIndoe highlights Dastmalchian’s charming yet shadowed lead performance and the film’s retro practical effects while noting some loss of tension midway.
Read the full review →N
The New York Times
21 March 2024 · Alissa Wilkinson
The critic finds the film a trimly effective horror pastiche that captures an occult-obsessed nation through its found-footage format of a late-night show gone wrong. She praises its nasty, delicious flair for menace and real-time structure that transforms viewers into 1977 audiences.
Read the full review →V
Variety
23 March 2023 · festival review · Dennis Harvey
The critic calls the film a clever construct blending found-footage horror with 1970s TV satire, where a live broadcast devolves into supernatural chaos. He praises its fresh satiric gloss on Me Decade showbiz cheese and deft handling by the directors, though notes its impact is more ingenious than indelible.
Read the full review →D
Digital Spy
22 March 2024 · Ian Sandwell
90*
The critic calls it the best horror movie of the year so far and one of the most inventive takes on found footage in years. They single out the original Ghostwatch-inspired approach, exceptional retro production design, and strong performances, particularly from newcomer Ingrid Torelli as Lilly.
Read the full review →P
Polygon
22 March 2024 · Austen Goslin
85*
The critic calls it the year’s most stylish horror movie thanks to its meticulous recreation of a 1970s late-night broadcast and its playful found-footage structure. They single out David Dastmalchian’s twitchy, transfixing lead performance for particular praise.
Read the full review →C
Collider
11 March 2023 · 8/10 · Chase Hutchinson
80
The review highlights Dastmalchian's commanding performance and the film's shift to fearsome fun when it embraces chaos, but notes the found footage framing can be restrictive.
Read the full review →D
Deadline
10 March 2023 · festival review · Damon Wise
75*
The critic finds the film an experiential, intelligent fusion of Network and Rosemary's Baby that delivers well on the organic goose-bump level of a well-told urban myth. He singles out the richly detailed recreation of 1970s late-night TV rituals and Dastmalchian's performance as the chat-show host for particular praise, while noting the ending adds some excess baggage.
Read the full review →F
Film Stories
22 March 2024 · Maria Lattila
75*
The critic praises the film's authentic 1970s late-night TV setting and especially David Dastmalchian's charismatic yet desperate lead performance as host Jack Delroy. They note strong direction and nightmarish imagery but wish there were more scares and question some aspects of the mockumentary structure.
Read the full review →P
Paste
18 March 2024 · 7.4 · Jacob Oller
The critic praises the film's commitment to the 1970s talk show format and David Dastmalchian's lead performance, calling it a winning midnight staple. They note it finds substance in its satirical script but occasionally loses control in the chaos.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate