Most critics respond warmly to Laura, praising Otto Preminger’s controlled direction and the way its romantic mystery draws on male obsession and fantasy. The praise clusters around the photography, the memorable score and a cast led by Gene Tierney, with Clifton Webb’s caustic, unsettling performance receiving particular attention. Several reviews find the character portraits as absorbing as the detective story, while others emphasise the suspense and unpredictable plotting.
The spread is wide, though the disagreement comes chiefly from one negative review rather than a divided consensus. Time Out finds the personalities and direction more compelling than the mystery itself, a reservation within an otherwise positive assessment. The New Yorker’s 1944 review dissents much more sharply, dismissing the film as an ordinary detective picture with uninteresting characters and clichéd dialogue. Even that review finds brief stimulation in Webb’s performance, making him a rare point of agreement across the divide.
