Critics’ reviews

Leave the World Behind (2023)

22 reviews from 22 publications. Critics’ score 67: 9 positive, 2 mixed, 2 negative.

Back to our review of Leave the World Behind

67
Positive
9
Mixed
2
Negative
2

Most critics like it, but the spread is wide. The praise settles on the cast: Julia Roberts is named again and again, with The Telegraph calling this her strongest cinema role in years, and Mahershala Ali and Ethan Hawke are singled out nearly as often. The reviews also agree that Esmail builds tension well in the first half, when two families are shut in a luxury house with the internet gone, and several note the off-kilter camerawork. The reservations gather around what happens once the crisis widens. The New York Times finds the film less effective the more explicit it becomes, Vulture finds the characters thin and the disaster sequences half-finished, and Empire says it never settles on a target. Several middling reviews complain that the politics are heavy-handed and that the ending withholds too much. The keenest supporters say the vagueness is the point; the doubters say it is a shrug dressed as profundity.

Screen Daily
26 October 2023 · festival review
80*

With Hitchcockian flair, it's a confident, entertaining thriller with excellent performances and superb escalation of tension; singles out Julia Roberts' commanding turn and the ensemble.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
26 November 2023
80*

The critic describes the film as a cracking apocalyptic thriller that is sharp-witted, bracingly bleak and immensely enjoyable. They single out the superb performances by Julia Roberts and Mahershala Ali along with the film's big-hitting ambition and spectacle tempered by humour.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
8 December 2023 · ★★★★ · Chief Film Critic
80

The critic praises the film as an enthralling thriller in which Julia Roberts delivers her best cinema role in years. They highlight the recognisable human behaviour driving the story and the way it plays on social tensions without becoming preachy.

Read the full review →
Variety
26 October 2023 · festival review · Peter Debruge
75*

Esmail delivers an intriguing, slow-burn thriller focused on human behavior and prejudice under pressure, with strong character work and a satisfying final scene.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★ · James Mottram
60

The critic finds it a fitfully engaging apocalypse drama with some spectacular sequences like the oil tanker but others like the deer herd that don't work; praises Julia Roberts' performance and the funny Friends subplot, notes it might suit TV better.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
5 December 2023 · Robert Daniels
55*

The film understands post-apocalyptic mechanics and features strong performances and dynamic camerawork but fails to generate meaningful stakes or emotional depth.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
7 December 2023 · Alissa Wilkinson
40*

The adaptation turns the novel’s ambiguity into something more explicit and less effective, going awry once the larger crisis is revealed.

Read the full review →
Vulture
8 December 2023 · Bilge Ebiri
30*

The critic finds the adaptation unconvincing as an apocalyptic thriller, with cardboard-cutout characters that the film shows little interest in and half-assed disaster sequences that fail to cohere. It piles on weird events without delivering compelling or terrifying visions of the end times.

Read the full review →
Empire
7 December 2023 · Lillian Crawford

The apocalyptic thriller collapses on itself despite a starry cast and suspenseful filmmaking. Esmail's adaptation fails to commit to any clear target amid hackneyed themes, poor CGI, and a baffling conclusion.

Read the full review →
Financial Times
23 November 2023 · ★★★★☆ · Danny Leigh

The critic finds the film an addictive parlour game and chewy treatise on human behaviour that upends archetypes in an Airbnb apocalypse scenario. They single out the way the characters' flawed, recognisable reactions and social frictions drive the story.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
26 October 2023 · festival review · Christian Zilko

The critic describes the film as a messy, well-meaning ode to staying human amid chaos that contains more ideas than it can address in two hours. It is an apocalyptic chamber piece that ultimately feels unfocused despite its strong cast.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
8 December 2023 · 6 · Steven Scaife

The critic finds the film an apocalypse thriller that thinks it is smarter than it is, content to blandly shrug in the direction of an amorphous societal chaos. It reaches for a profundity that it fails to achieve after losing its edge once initial tensions dissipate.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
26 October 2023 · festival review · Stephen Farber

The critic finds the film sometimes effective as a nightmarish suspense drama about everyday life disintegrating but heavy-handed and unsurprising on its political themes of racial suspicion and environmental catastrophe. Fine performances bolster a problematic picture that offers a few jolts but little fresh insight.

Read the full review →
The Times
24 November 2023 · ★★★★☆ · Kevin Maher

The critic calls the film a riveting thriller and social satire that combines survivalist drama with pointed commentary on post-pandemic paranoia. They single out the flawless performances and sensational shooting style.

Read the full review →
Total Film
7 December 2023 · Kate Stables

Esmail delivers a glossy but uneven dystopian drama that cranks up suspense effectively at times but feels torn between racial tensions and CGI disasters. The bickering characters ultimately limit emotional investment in the plausible chaos.

Read the full review →
Collider
4 December 2023 · B+ · Ross Bonaime
83

Esmail adapts the novel into a tense, small-scale end-of-the-world drama focused on two families trapped in a luxury home amid a cyberattack and blackout. The film excels due to strong performances, especially from Julia Roberts, Ethan Hawke, and Mahershala Ali, along with unsettling camerawork that heightens the sense of helplessness.

Read the full review →
Digital Spy
8 December 2023 · Ian Sandwell
80*

The critic calls it one of Netflix's best movies of the year and a gripping, intense apocalyptic thriller adapted by Sam Esmail. It features excellent performances, a distinct offbeat style and tone that keeps viewers hooked despite offering no easy answers to its mysteries.

Read the full review →
Paste
7 December 2023 · 7.5/10 · Brianna Zigler
75

Esmail delivers a surprisingly light and adventurous take on apocalypse that feels like old-school sci-fi blockbusters, with strong tension, atmosphere, and charismatic star performances. The film creates gripping momentum and wonder even as it explores themes of mistrust and difference in crisis, though the ideas are not always as tightly executed as the execution.

Read the full review →
Polygon
8 December 2023 · Oli Welsh
75*

Esmail stages a gripping view of apocalypse from inside a wealthy bubble, using surreal imagery and interpersonal tension between the two families to explore fragility and shared privilege. The film is most assured in its mysterious, bottle-episode setup and strong casting, though it struggles to land on deeper answers about identity or society.

Read the full review →
/Film
7 December 2023 · 7/10 · Chris Evangelista
70

The critic finds the film a quirky, bleak, weird, and funny apocalyptic story that works despite its deliberate vagueness and lack of answers. They single out the off-kilter cinematography and the film's unflinching hopelessness as refreshing.

Read the full review →
Deadline
26 October 2023 · festival review · Pete Hammond

The critic calls the film a riveting and entertaining social thriller that offers a warning to humanity about technology and control, with strong performances especially from Mahershala Ali and Julia Roberts. It stands out for blending disaster elements with paranoia and social commentary rather than relying on typical spectacle.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
26 October 2023

The critic praises the film as one of the year’s best for its taut, terrifying descent into chaos that feels all too real, anchored by Mahershala Ali’s empathetic performance. It singles out the script’s exploration of racism, misinformation, and loss of control as particularly compelling amid strong ensemble work.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate