Most critics find Legend more persuasive as a visual fantasy than as a story, with praise clustering around its imagery, design and costumes. Even the less favourable reviews acknowledge the appeal of its fairy-tale setting, while Tim Curry’s Lord of Darkness receives particular praise for bringing some life to the proceedings. Tangerine Dream’s score also earns approval, though these strengths seldom outweigh complaints about thin characters and a lack of emotional involvement.
The disagreement centres on how much those visual pleasures can compensate for the storytelling. Slant Magazine offers the clearest defence, celebrating the film’s transportive style while acknowledging that character development suffers. The less enthusiastic reviews find the imagery insufficient, with reservations ranging from blunt symbolism and kitsch to a shortage of wit and invention. Across the relevant reviews, admiration for the craft is considerably more widespread than enthusiasm for the film.
