Most critics like Liar Liar, and mostly for Jim Carrey. The reviews agree that the premise, a lawyer who cannot lie for a day, is built to suit his physical and vocal contortions, and that Tom Shadyac’s direction consists largely of pointing the camera at him. Several call it a return to form after The Cable Guy, and a few notice a more human side beneath the mania.
The reservations cluster on the plot around the performance. Many find the story formulaic and the father-and-son material sugary, with Variety complaining that the final reel lays the sentiment on too thick. Two reviews dissent outright. The New Yorker thinks the film loses its nerve, calming down after an energetic middle and wasting the disorder the premise promises, while The AV Club finds it a Disney comedy with crude jokes added and Carrey’s excess more tiring than funny. Otherwise the spread is narrow; nobody sits on the fence.
