Most critics find Love Wedding Repeat a laboured farce that squanders a promising idea; seven of the twelve reviews are negative. Where there is praise, it goes to the cast rather than the script: Tim Key’s comic delivery, Aisling Bea, Jack Farthing, Olivia Munn’s relaxed presence, and the easy sibling rapport between Sam Claflin and Eleanor Tomlinson are each singled out as bright spots. The Italian setting and handsome production values are noted approvingly too.
The complaints cluster on the premise. Several say the repeat conceit arrives too late or fails to pay off, and that the characters never rise above types, leaving the central romance thin. Some also find the cringe comedy unfunny and the shifts in tone awkward. The spread is wide: Variety stands alone in calling the escalating wedding-day mishaps captivating and Claflin charming, while IndieWire and NME sit in the middle, amused but unconvinced.
