The reviews split widely, and the split is about tone. Most critics agree on what the film is: a bright, self-aware reboot that keeps winking at how silly He-Man is, with Nicholas Galitzine playing him as a sweet, slightly bewildered dork rather than a strongman. The praise clusters there, on Galitzine’s performance, on Travis Knight’s colourful production and staging, and on the villains, with Skeletor named more than once as the best thing in it. The reservations cluster on the joking. A large minority find the constant apologising for its own corniness exhausting, and several say the script cannot decide whether it is parody or earnest adventure. The 141-minute runtime is a recurring complaint. Polygon is the outlier at the top, calling it close to a perfect fantasy adventure; The Wrap and The Telegraph sit at the bottom, treating it as an embarrassed misfire. The British broadsheets are noticeably harsher than the American trades.
T
Time Out
2 June 2026 · ★★★★ · Larushka Ivan-Zadeh
80
The critic praises this colorful, nostalgic reboot as a fun, irreverent fantasy adventure that captures the cartoon's joyful spirit and offers a timely antidote to toxic masculinity. Travis Knight's direction is singled out for bringing bright energy and heart to the material.
Read the full review →A
The AV Club
2 June 2026 · C+ · Jesse Hassenger
63
The critic calls it a fitfully amusing redo that clears a low bar set by the 1987 version but remains too cute and inconsistent. Skeletor stands out as the weird highlight amid the self-conscious jokes and toy-loving sincerity.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
2 June 2026 · ★★★ · Alan Jones
60
The review finds the film starts with promise in its day-glo fantasy setup and cast performances but ultimately lacks the spark to elevate it beyond standard blockbuster fare. Tonal inconsistencies and an overlong, uneven script are highlighted as drawbacks.
Read the full review →I
IndieWire
2 June 2026 · David Ehrlich
50*
The review portrays the film as a derivative fantasy epic that gives He-Man the Barbie treatment, emphasizing big muscles over heart while still celebrating them. It highlights the lead's performance as a swole himbo in a story that struggles to balance sincerity and satire.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
2 June 2026 · Frank Scheck
35*
The critic finds the film exhaustingly jokey and forced in its self-referential humor, making it mainly appealing to hardcore fans rather than a broad audience. The relentless camp and lame gags undermine any genuine engagement with the material.
Read the full review →E
Empire
2 June 2026 · Helen O’Hara
Travis Knight takes a winking approach to the self-aware source material and leans into its ridiculousness in a way that largely works. The result is a colourful, fun chase movie that appeals to kids and nostalgic adults alike, though it could use sharper scripting and more narrative drive.
Read the full review →E
Evening Standard
4 June 2026 · Hannah Pettit
Nicholas Galitzine embodies a modern, sensitive version of He-Man in this light-hearted, self-aware reboot that updates the character with a toxic-masculinity-averse approach. Action sequences thrill but feel generic, humour sometimes undercuts emotional beats, and the film struggles to stand out among other reboots despite its charisma and spectacle.
Read the full review →F
Financial Times
4 June 2026 · Raphael Abraham
The critic finds the film embarrassed by its own premise of muscles and male heroism, constantly apologising for its existence through innuendo and self-satire. It singles out the thin sticking plasters of humour that eventually wear thin.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
3 June 2026 · Amy Nicholson
The critic praises Knight and Galitzine for modernizing the macho character into a sensitive, self-aware comedy about masculinity, with Galitzine embracing the dorky human side. The flat script and obvious humor are noted as drawbacks amid the fan service and effects.
Read the full review →The critic notes the film's playful, self-deprecating approach to its source material and Knight's attempt to add humanity to franchise fare, but concludes it fails to sustain its charm over the extended runtime. The mix of irreverence and conventional action is seen as hit-or-miss.
Read the full review →The critic calls the film a weak big-budget misfire and a $200m waste of time on outdated toy IP. The main complaint is the script's crippling indecision between winking parody and earnest adventure, resulting in an awkward, unfulfilling experience.
Read the full review →N
The New York Times
4 June 2026 · Glenn Kenny
The critic sees the film as a self-aware corporate blockbuster that acknowledges the goofiness of He-Man and benefits from a sincere yet skewed approach. Galitzine delivers in the action sequences after a loose, amusing performance as the mild-mannered hero.
Read the full review →The critic describes the reboot as a brain-vaporising misfire that constantly tells viewers how right they are not to enjoy it. It singles out the constant self-aware jokes about its own corniness and datedness as the central flaw.
Read the full review →The critic examines the attempt to update the He-Man property for modern audiences with added gay innuendo, questioning whether it can succeed like Barbie. The tone mixes irreverence with the challenges of retooling the 1980s toy franchise.
Read the full review →V
Variety
2 June 2026 · Guy Lodge
The critic finds the film a jokey but bloated nostalgia trip that lampshades its own uncoolness without fully committing, feeling past its time at 141 minutes. Galitzine provides spark as the bewildered hero, but the script's mix of earnestness and irony falters in the extended action.
Read the full review →P
Polygon
2 June 2026 · Jake Kleinman
90*
The critic hails the film as a nearly perfect sci-fi fantasy epic that looks stunning and rejects the dark, grounded style of modern blockbusters. They single out the vibrant, colorful visuals and sincere maximalist spectacle for praise.
Read the full review →D
Deadline
2 June 2026 · Pete Hammond
80*
The critic finds the film works on its own terms with a younger attitude, genuine humor, and an appealing performance from Nicholas Galitzine as He-Man. They single out the light and moving tone and script, along with strong production values and battles staged by director Travis Knight.
Read the full review →C
Consequence
2 June 2026 · B
77
The critic praises the film's decision to embrace a silly, campy, and self-aware tone rather than taking the material too seriously. They single out the goofy approach to the iconic costume and characters as a highlight that makes the adventure fun.
Read the full review →D
Den of Geek
2 June 2026 · ★★★ · David Crow
60
The film attempts to blend a nostalgic 1980s kids' adventure with self-aware postmodern comedy but struggles with tonal dissonance, resulting in a confused mix that undercuts its emotional beats. It succeeds more with the villains, particularly Jared Leto's Skeletor and Alison Brie's Evil-Lyn, than with its hero's journey or attempts at deeper themes.
Read the full review →The critic calls it a confused and embarrassed sci-fi fantasy flop that is sloppy and could kill 1980s nostalgia. They complain about the inconsistent message on violence, cheap-looking effects despite expense, and smug self-awareness that embarrasses the source material.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate