The reviews are largely warm, and several critics call this the best of the standalone Minions films. The praise clusters in one place: the 1920s Hollywood setting and its steady run of nods to silent cinema, which most reviewers say gives the usual slapstick a shape it has lacked. The voice cast and the monster designs draw approving mentions, as does the world building of the period setting. The reservations cluster too. Variety and The Hollywood Reporter both feel the film is at its sharpest in the first half and loses momentum once the monsters arrive and the pace turns frantic, and The AV Club finds the slapstick disjointed in places. The spread is otherwise narrow, with one clear dissenter: The Guardian argues the promising setup gives way to repetitive franchise chaos and that the attempt to give the Minions pathos is undone by cluttered plotting. Nobody else is that severe.
The review calls it a delightful homage to classic Hollywood silent films. It praises the clever nods to early cinema and the anarchic storytelling that entertains both kids and cinephiles.
Read the full review →