Critics’ reviews

Official Secrets (2019)

23 reviews from 23 publications. Critics’ score 64: 14 positive, 6 mixed, 3 negative.

Back to our review of Official Secrets

64
Positive
14
Mixed
6
Negative
3
Los Angeles Times
27 August 2019 · Kenneth Turan
80*

A crackling political thriller that effectively dramatizes a principled stand against the Iraq War with brisk pacing and strong performances. It singles out Keira Knightley's portrayal of a moral exemplar for particular praise.

Read the full review →
Time Out
13 October 2019 · ★★★★ · Phil de Semlyen
80

Hood’s follow-up to Eye in the Sky is a pacy, palm-clammying mix of tense spy thriller and journo procedural that examines moral corruption at the highest level without restoring trust in the powers that be.

Read the full review →
Vulture
29 August 2019
80*

The Brits do low-key, paranoid procedural dramas like this one well, with a pervading chill and no flash. Hood frames the story to suggest constant surveillance, and the crispness cuts like a knife while highlighting a conscience in torment.

Read the full review →
Financial Times
16 October 2019 · Danny Leigh
75*

Director Gavin Hood cranks the tension in this real-life chronicle of courage about Katharine Gun's leak. The film serves as a valuable dark reminder of how the journey to the present political mood accelerated wildly in 2003.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
29 January 2019 · festival review
70*

A sturdy, entertaining political thriller that pushes all the right buttons, with Knightley persuasive as the whistleblower Gun and Hood mixing thrills with political commentary effectively despite familiar journalistic drama tropes.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
17 October 2019 · Matthew Taylor
70*

The film is a solid, spiralling spy procedural elevated by Knightley’s ascetic, intensely focused performance as Katharine Gun, which serves as its true north amid the procedural threads and state apparatus chill.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
27 August 2019 · B- · Mike D'Angelo
70

The film recounts Gun’s story in a dry, procedural synopsis that rarely deviates from the standard whistleblower template and settles for didactic point-scoring. It shines a light on a nearly forgotten Iraq War whistleblower whose conscience stands as a pointed reminder.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
18 October 2019 · Peter Bradshaw
70*

Knightley gives a focused, plausible and sympathetic performance as the whistleblower Katharine Gun in this shrewd and relevant spy drama. The film highlights the British establishment's tendency to spite under pressure and the importance of young, vulnerable people speaking out against government actions.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
29 January 2019 · festival review · David Rooney
70*

Hood and his cast deliver a straightforward, solidly old-fashioned slice of real-life espionage and intrigue that gets the job done in engrossing, clear-eyed fashion even if it lacks much stylistic verve. The film is a dutiful reminder of a shameful episode in recent history.

Read the full review →
The Times
17 October 2019 · ★★★★☆ · Kevin Maher
70*

The film opts for unadorned journalistic clarity over cinematic clichés in telling the true story of Katharine Gun. Knightley delivers a power-player performance that holds the show together with minimalism and emotional depth.

Read the full review →
Variety
29 January 2019 · festival review · Amy Nicholson
70*

A staid but honorable and ennobling account of a whistleblower's failed attempt to avert the Iraq War. It singles out the genteel institutional critique and the defense lawyer's courtroom strategy for attention.

Read the full review →
Empire
14 October 2019 · Ian Freer
65*

The film is an entertaining slice of recent history celebrating an unsung British hero, anchored by a strong Keira Knightley performance, but let down by a simplistic take on its complex subject matter.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
28 August 2019 · Manohla Dargis
55*

The film is a coherent but uneven retelling of Katharine Gun's whistleblowing that struggles to generate excitement or depth. It singles out the office printer scene and journalistic portrayals for note while criticizing flat suspense and underdeveloped characters.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
18 October 2019 · David Sexton
35*

The story is important with good casting, but the film lacks action, visual excitement and suspense, remaining too diligently true to life and earnest to take off as drama.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
30 August 2019 · Jude Dry
30*

Knightley risks treason in a sober real-life Iraq War drama, but Matt Smith, Ralph Fiennes, and Matthew Goode fill out this inert drama about a whistleblower who leaked a top secret NSA memo.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
19 August 2019 · Chuck Bowen
30*

Hood’s film is a muckraking thriller that revels in wonderfully lived-in details as well as generic biopic platitudes and wrings suspense out of the parsing of evidence. It is ambitious but prone to melodrama that reduces the protagonist to a supporting character in her own story.

Read the full review →
Deadline
27 August 2019 · Pete Hammond
90*

The film is a pulse-pounding true drama and the most gripping thriller of 2019, with Hood turning the story into a white-knuckle thriller. It singles out Keira Knightley's never-better performance as the whistleblower with a conscience.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
7 February 2019 · festival review · Jeremy Mathews
80*

The critic highlights the film's refreshing straight-forwardness and focus on Katharine Gun's decision and its consequences, praising Knightley's quiet conviction and the inspirational portrayal of people working together for the right thing.

Read the full review →
Den of Geek
15 October 2019 · 3 out of 5 · Caroline Preece
70*

The critic finds it a solid but muted retelling of the whistleblower story, praising Keira Knightley's captivating performance as Katharine Gun but noting the film doesn't quite match her intensity, excelling more in its newsroom drama sections.

Read the full review →
Film Stories
18 October 2019 · Katie Smith-Wong
60*

The critic praises Keira Knightley's mature and compelling performance as Katharine Gun but criticizes the film's uneven tone and lack of punch, calling it a safe retelling of the scandal.

Read the full review →
Collider
29 January 2019 · C · Matt Goldberg
57

The critic finds the film a dry, unremarkable chronicle that fails to capture emotional depth or focus on the protagonist's story effectively. They praise the subject's courage but criticize the direction for making it inert and Wikipedia-like.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
31 January 2019 · C- · Jordan Ruimy
50

The critic finds the film pedestrian and uninspired with dull direction that fails to focus on the heroine or convey impact, despite a strong performance from Knightley, resulting in a failed attempt at the story.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
27 August 2019
50*

The film is high-minded and sturdy but never as galvanizing as it should be, serving as an efficiently told primer on ordinary bravery. It singles out the fascinating second-half legal peril and defense machinations for praise amid mixed results for the journalism and thriller elements.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate