
Most critics respond warmly to Pain and Glory, praising Almodóvar’s personal account of ageing, memory and the difficulty of making art when health falters. Antonio Banderas draws the strongest agreement: the reviews repeatedly single out his quiet, vulnerable performance as the ailing filmmaker, finding considerable feeling in his restraint. Praise also centres on the controlled use of colour, the movement between past and present, and the tenderness of the encounters with people from the director’s past.
The differences concern how involving this self-examination becomes, with responses ranging from deeply moved to distinctly reserved. The AV Club admires Banderas but finds the reckonings remote and unfocused, while The Telegraph considers the writing uneven, despite touching reunion scenes. The Hollywood Reporter is more resistant to the autobiographical approach, finding it self-regarding and chiefly rewarding for devotees. For most critics, however, the gentler storytelling makes the memories and reconciliations more affecting.
T
Time Out
7 May 2019 · ★★★★★ · Josep Lambies
100
The film is hailed as a gorgeous, humane journey into an ageing filmmaker’s soul and one of Almodóvar’s most autobiographical works. The critic singles out the poignant tapestry of recollections and Banderas’s haunted performance.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
2 October 2019 · Kenneth Turan
90*
Almodóvar is at his best, forging dazzling new paths while remaining completely himself in a dramatic rather than melodramatic autobiographical work. It concerns the creative impulse and the power of the past to revive and enlighten the present.
Read the full review →R
RogerEbert.com
3 October 2019 · festival review · Brian Tallerico
90*
The film is a deeply personal and very moving work anchored by Antonio Banderas's best performance. It explores how pain and life shape art through an aging director's memories and reunions.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
25 August 2019 · Peter Bradshaw
90*
The critic praises this deeply personal autofictional work as bittersweet perfection and richly satisfying, highlighting Antonio Banderas's career-best performance as the stand-in for the director in crisis.
Read the full review →F
Film Comment
1 March 2019 · Manuel Yáñez Murillo
85*
The critic praises Almodóvar’s most cohesive and confessional film yet, a heart-rending meditation on memory, autofiction, and the director’s own life and ailments. Banderas delivers a nuanced performance as the surrogate filmmaker Salvador, with the film balancing personal warmth against historical and medical pain through restrained, fluid storytelling.
Read the full review →N
The New Yorker
3 October 2019 · Anthony Lane
85*
Almodóvar has made one of his richest and most sombre films, gathering obsessions in an autumnal tale of ailments, memory and truthtelling. The film revives its protagonist through the act of describing his fading illusions and mortal health.
Read the full review →V
Variety
17 May 2019 · Critics Pick · Peter Debruge
85*
This remarkably mature metafiction explores the emotional scars underlying the director’s physical frailty with signature touches and a subtler authenticity. It rejects broad melodrama for direct confessional storytelling.
Read the full review →V
Vulture
5 October 2019 · David Edelstein
85*
The critic describes it as the gentlest and most emotionally naked movie Almodóvar has ever made, a confessional work that holds together with vulnerability and a simple, poignant closing image between mother and child that finally releases the tears.
Read the full review →L
Little White Lies
20 August 2019 · 4/4/5 · Adam Woodward
80
Almodóvar delivers an exquisite, soulful self-portrait that builds a complex picture of a gifted but flawed artist. The critic highlights the film’s masterful handling of memory, addiction and late-career clarity.
Read the full review →i
The i Paper
22 August 2019 · ★★★★ · Nick Hasted
80
The critic praises this masterfully understated meditation on outliving notoriety and health while still making art from memory. They highlight Banderas's atypically quiet, Cannes-winning performance as the washed-up director.
Read the full review →T
The Times
24 August 2019 · ★★★★
80
The critic calls it a beautiful and reflective work about an artist taking stock of his creativity and the pleasures of art, with strong performances and visual beauty throughout.
Read the full review →A
The AV Club
1 October 2019 · B- · Mike D'Angelo
70
The critic praises Banderas’ rich, gravity-filled performance as the aging director but finds the film relatively low on actual pain or glory, with low-key reckonings that feel disappointingly remote and unfocused despite tender moments and stylish direction.
Read the full review →T
The Telegraph
17 May 2019 · ★★★
60
The review finds Antonio Banderas deeply touching but calls the film an uneven effort in self-reflexive nostalgia, with writing that is banal in parts but lifts in key reunion scenes.
Read the full review →E
Empire
19 August 2019 · Ian Freer
The critic describes it as a moving, meditative work of self-reflection and a major achievement, with Almodóvar turning inward. They single out Banderas's world-weary yet intimate performance and the film's beautiful control of colour, memory transitions and tenderness.
Read the full review →E
Evening Standard
23 August 2019 · David Sexton
The critic calls the film delicious and perfectly poised, leaving viewers feeling better about the world. They single out Banderas's vulnerable, career-redefining performance and the film's many tender acts of reconciliation across time.
Read the full review →I
IndieWire
17 May 2019 · festival review · Eric Kohn
The review calls it Almodóvar’s best movie in years and his most personal, with Antonio Banderas excelling as a version of the auteur in what comes closest to a memoir. It highlights the intimate, confessional quality of the semi-autobiographical work.
Read the full review →S
Screen Daily
15 May 2019 · festival review
Almodóvar’s introspective film is seen as a thinly veiled deep dive into the director’s own life, with strong performances but a cautious distance that keeps the audience at arm’s length until a superbly acted core scene. The Cannes competition entry is noted for revisiting familiar themes through opiate-fuelled reverie.
Read the full review →S
Sight and Sound
21 August 2019 · Maria Delgado
The critic praises Almodóvar’s latest as a richly layered work that uses reminiscence to explore both personal history and contemporary Spanish politics. Banderas’s restrained performance as the ailing filmmaker is singled out as anchoring the film’s emotional and intellectual depth.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
21 March 2019 · festival review · Jonathan Holland
The critic sees the film as a thinly disguised autobiographical roundup of Almodóvar’s life and work that is exquisitely crafted and visually sumptuous but self-regarding and inward-looking. It is unlikely to be remembered fondly except by diehards, with strong performances and nostalgia for women and sexuality singled out amid its focus on pain over glory.
Read the full review →N
The New York Times
3 October 2019 · NYT Critic’s Pick · Manohla Dargis
Almodóvar’s sublime film circles around art as self-creation in a contemplative story of memory, loss and imagination. It is visually striking with an elegantly structured narrative and powerful restraint.
Read the full review →T
Total Film
18 May 2019 · festival review
The critic finds it a fascinating, pensive addition to Almodóvar's oeuvre for aficionados, with superb work from Banderas in key scenes, though it covers too much familiar ground comfortably. They single out the recreation of the director's own apartment and the emotional payoff of past figures returning.
Read the full review →/
/Film
12 September 2019 · 9/10 · Chris Evangelista
90
Almodóvar's most autobiographical work is a tender, introspective portrait of an ageing filmmaker reflecting on personal pain, past relationships and creativity. The episodic structure, stunning visuals and Banderas's performance create a lush, enchanting experience that builds to a masterful conclusion.
Read the full review →D
Deadline
2 October 2019 · Pete Hammond
85*
The critic calls it Almodóvar’s most personal film yet, likening it to his own 8½, and praises Banderas for a career-best performance as the ailing director reflecting on his life. They single out the tender reunion scene with an old lover and the luminous supporting turn by Penélope Cruz.
Read the full review →C
Collider
20 May 2019 · B+ · Gregory Ellwood
83
The critic finds Pain and Glory to be Almodóvar’s most personal film yet but notes the first half feels arduous before Banderas opens up a new side to his character. It ultimately celebrates the director’s decision to disclose what he sees fit, ending on a glorious shot that reminds viewers life is a melodrama.
Read the full review →D
Den of Geek
21 August 2019 · ★★★★ · Mark Harrison
80
The review highlights Almodóvar’s self-reflective portrait of a filmmaker confronting pain and memory, carried by Banderas’s career-best dramatic performance. It notes the film’s two halves united by its contemplative depiction of creativity and the past, though the structure feels slightly uneven.
Read the full review →E
Eye for Film
18 May 2019 · festival review · Richard Mowe
Almodóvar's most personal film yet follows an ageing gay filmmaker confronting depression, ill health and creative decline through reflections on his past. Banderas delivers a stunning performance as the director's alter ego, with the film achieving a bitter-sweet tone through simplicity and emotional engagement.
Read the full review →F
Film Stories
2 September 2019 · Amanda Keats
Almodóvar delivers a poetic exploration of art, love, legacy and family through the story of an ageing director reflecting on his life and pain. The film excels in its attention to human connections, vivid colours and textures, and Banderas's raw, understated performance, though it takes time to find its stride.
Read the full review →W
The Wrap
2 October 2019 · festival review · Steve Pond
The critic describes it as a lovely, gentle reverie and a rapturous meditation on past and present that nourishes rather than provokes. They single out Banderas’ quiet, affecting performance as the weary director and the film’s mature introspection and impeccable visual style.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate