Critics’ reviews

Picnic at Hanging Rock (1975)

9 reviews from 9 publications. Critics’ score 82: 9 positive, 0 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of Picnic at Hanging Rock

82
Positive
9
Mixed
0
Negative
0

The reviews are unanimously positive, with praise clustering around Peter Weir’s command of atmosphere and the unsettling Australian landscape. Most critics value the film’s suggestiveness, finding dread and repressed desire in its schoolgirl mystery rather than treating it as a puzzle to be solved. Empire singles out Russell Boyd’s cinematography, while the broader consensus admires the way the sunlit setting becomes strange and threatening. Sexual repression and Victorian propriety are recurring points of interest.

The differences are chiefly in enthusiasm and interpretation, rather than explicit objections. Scores range from 70 to 90, but even the more measured assessments praise the poetic mood and nature’s disturbing presence. The Guardian stresses imperial anxiety and sexual hysteria; Eye for Film finds adolescent tensions especially rewarding, while acknowledging the mystery’s frustrating quality. There is no clear dissenting review, nor a shared complaint about performance, pacing or construction.

The AV Club
29 March 2002 · Keith Phipps
90*

The film is a beautifully shot, haunted, and haunting movie and a classic example of the power of suggestiveness, elusiveness, and understatement. It helped initiate the first wave of interest in Australian moviemaking and is a peerless mystery in the truest sense of the word.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
20 February 2025
90*

Peter Weir’s 1975 film is a classic of the Australian new wave cinema, a supernatural parable of imperial anxiety and sexual hysteria that remains dazzling on its 50th anniversary re-release. The critic singles out its sun-stricken hallucinatory strangeness and the way it affects the manner of a true-crime cold case around an unknowable enigma at the rock.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
14 January 1980 · ★★★½/4 · Roger Ebert
88

Weir's film creates a haunting mystery around the unexplained disappearance of schoolgirls and a teacher on a picnic, evoking buried terror and repressed sexuality in a lush Australian landscape. Ebert praises its deliberate inconclusiveness and hypnotic, enigmatic quality over any tidy resolution.

Read the full review →
Empire
1 January 2000 · Ian Nathan
85*

The critic calls it a haunting and compelling oddity from Peter Weir, part mystery, part horror, and an impressionist poem to lost innocence. The sumptuous and captivating cinematography by Russell Boyd is singled out for praise, along with the film's emphasis on nature's alien quality and its refusal to provide straightforward answers.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
25 June 1998 · Kevin Thomas
85*

Weir's director's cut revival is exquisite and seductive, showcasing masterful mood and suggestiveness with the rock as a brooding presence and the story's erotic symbolism. Thomas calls it a gorgeous-looking, superbly wrought enigma that helped revive Australian cinema.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
29 January 2025 · J. Hoberman
80*

The restored 1975 film is a national treasure epitomizing the 'outback uncanny,' with its tale of girls and a teacher vanishing from a prehistoric rock formation amid Victorian propriety. Hoberman highlights its quasi-supernatural atmosphere and status as Australia's greatest movie.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
· James Bell
70*

The film became a breakthrough for Australian cinema with its poetic mood and sumptuous cinematography. It revolves around the unexplained disappearance of schoolgirls at the rock, evoking ancestral ghosts and the tension between Victorian attitudes and the rugged landscape.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
30 June 2014 · Chris Cabin
70*

Desire as persistent and intense as the sunshine on a bright summer day teases out madness in Peter Weir’s Picnic at Hanging Rock. The power of nature is quiet but all-consuming in this unclassifiable work, which Criterion gives an astonishing A/V transfer.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
18 March 2009 · Jennie Kermode
85*

The critic praises Weir's graceful adaptation for capturing the book's mysterious and frustrating spirit along with its magical atmosphere rooted in aboriginal Dreamtime traditions. They single out the exploration of adolescent tensions, sensuality, and repression at the all-girls school as a key strength.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate