Most critics like Priscilla. The praise clusters around Cailee Spaeny, whose quiet performance is singled out again and again for carrying Priscilla from schoolgirl to wife without a false note, and around Sofia Coppola’s decision to keep Elvis at the edge of the frame and tell the story from inside the gilded cage. The costumes, the production design and the soundtrack choices come in for regular admiration. The reservations are milder and mostly shared: several reviews find the later stretches slacken, the ending arrives abruptly, and the tone is more muted than Coppola’s earlier work. The spread is narrow; twenty-one of the twenty-six reviews are favourable. The dissenters do not dispute the craft. The Evening Standard finds the repetition of Priscilla’s boredom wearing, Collider thinks the film plays it safe and settles for a compilation of a bad marriage, and The Independent warns that its dourness will sit badly with Elvis fans.
i
The i Paper
3 January 2024 · Christina Newland
90*
The critic praises the film as a lyrical, cautionary exploration of toxic love and girlhood desire from Priscilla's perspective, highlighting Spaeny's vulnerable performance and the seductive yet isolating world Coppola creates. It elevates beyond its glamorous trappings to feel transcendent and great.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
4 September 2023 · festival review · David Rooney
85*
Coppola delivers a subdued but stirring portrait of Priscilla Presley’s years with Elvis, centering the young woman’s perspective with emotional transparency via Spaeny’s performance. The film is an impeccable union of director and subject, with nuanced restraint and sumptuous textures.
Read the full review →A
The AV Club
2 November 2023 · B+ · Lauren Coates
83
Coppola paints an elegant, introspective portrait of the troubled marriage that shatters rose-tinted myths around Elvis while highlighting the power imbalance. Spaeny gives a breakout performance as the quiet, inner-strength heart of the story, supported by strong production design and costumes.
Read the full review →E
Empire
20 December 2023 · Beth Webb
80*
The critic describes it as textbook Sofia Coppola, a meticulously crafted melodrama focusing on Priscilla's journey through a toxic marriage, with soaring portrayal of her growth and excellent work from Spaeny and Elordi. The woozy aesthetic and focus on loneliness make it a sublime continuation of the director's style.
Read the full review →L
Little White Lies
26 December 2023 · 3/4/5 · Hannah Strong
80
The review calls the film subtle and sensational, praising Cailee Spaeny's remarkable performance as a star is born in this biographical drama. It singles out the delicate portrayal of the all-consuming fire of first love and the realization that the fairytale does not always end happily.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
★★★★ · James Mottram
80
The review calls it a delicate, sensitive biopic seen through the eyes of the woman who knew Elvis best, based on her memoir. It singles out the attention to detail in costumes and design as pitch perfect while noting the final act lacks some emotional impact.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
31 December 2023
80*
Coppola delivers a stylish, sensitive portrait of Priscilla's gilded-cage existence that balances empathy for the central relationship with a modern awareness of its power imbalances. The film excels in its nuanced depiction of isolation and gradual emancipation, particularly through costume and anachronistic music choices.
Read the full review →T
The Telegraph
1 January 2024 · ★★★★ · Robbie Collin
80
Coppola's film succeeds by keeping Elvis firmly in the background and focusing on Priscilla's perspective, resulting in a beautiful and affecting portrait of a young woman in a gilded cage. The absence of Elvis songs and the emphasis on visual and emotional detail make it a distinctive and moving work.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
4 September 2023 · ★★★★ · Phil de Semlyen
80
The critic presents the film as a stylish dark-edged fairy tale and tart rejoinder to other depictions of Elvis, centering Priscilla's side of the story as a pink-hued prison movie. It singles out the empathetic approach that hands agency back to the young heroine without stern moral judgment.
Read the full review →S
Sight and Sound
12 September 2023 · festival review
75*
The critic describes Coppola's film as a heartsore biopic offering an ethereal, interior portrait of Priscilla Presley's troubled years with Elvis through dreamlike montages. It highlights the director's talent for creating substance from surface details and the inside-outside disconnect in the relationship.
Read the full review →N
The New Yorker
13 November 2023 · Molly Fischer
75*
Coppola explores the vexed archetype of the schoolgirl through Priscilla's journey into and out of Graceland. The film examines the ordinary experience of being desired for one's youth taken to a fantastical extreme.
Read the full review →The film immerses viewers in Priscilla’s girlish fantasy and wish-fulfillment while revealing the disturbing power differential and isolation in her relationship with Elvis. It is an uncomfortable yet thoroughly engaging watch, most vibrant in its early romance sequences and Spaeny’s performance.
Read the full review →S
Screen Daily
4 September 2023 · festival review
70*
The review notes that audiences will see Priscilla as groomed and Elvis as controlling and abusive, painting a darker picture than other films through a soft, subtle approach. It singles out the muted sensitivity and enveloping design as strengths, with the softly-softly method as the film's ultimate power.
Read the full review →T
Total Film
4 September 2023 · Jane Crowther
70*
The critic calls it a beguiling, evocative companion piece to other Elvis films, praising Coppola's creation of atmosphere, production design, and Spaeny's expressive performance amid themes of love and toxic fame. It notes some issues like an abrupt ending and more muted tone than the director's other work.
Read the full review →S
Slant Magazine
4 October 2023 · festival review · David Robb
60*
Coppola returns to familiar territory with a photogenic tale of fame and female desire, effective in its early courtship scenes but hindered by its expanded scope that obscures emotional subtleties. The result feels tasteful yet empty, stranded between specificity and spectacle.
Read the full review →I
The Independent
26 December 2023
50*
The critic sees the film as a sparse, downbeat drama depicting Elvis as an insecure narcissist who grooms and controls the teenage Priscilla, resulting in her loss of freedom in a gilded cage. Strong performances from Spaeny and Elordi are noted, but the overall tone is dour and uncomfortable for Elvis fans compared to more exuberant biopics.
Read the full review →E
Evening Standard
9 October 2023 · festival review · Jo-Ann Titmarsh
40*
The critic finds little new in Coppola's sympathetic but repetitive take on the well-known story, with the film emphasizing Priscilla's boredom and lack of agency in a controlling environment. While it has stylish moments and good performances, the screenplay and repetitive structure make it hard not to feel bored.
Read the full review →F
Financial Times
3 January 2024 · ★★★★☆ · Danny Leigh
The film offers a woozy, on-brand Coppola portrait of Priscilla as a bright but naive teenager drawn into Elvis's orbit, with a subtle modern lens on the past. It finds something beyond mere tragedy in her story, emphasizing suggestion over editorialising.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
27 October 2023 · Justin Chang
Coppola charts the young woman's struggle with exquisite patience and pointillist detail in a story of too-young love and power imbalances. The film shimmers with beauty and heartbreak and is her strongest in more than a decade.
Read the full review →N
The New York Times
26 October 2023 · Critic’s Pick · Ben Kenigsberg
Coppola re-examines the Elvis Presley story from Priscilla's viewpoint as a young woman drawn into a lonely, isolating world. The film highlights her sensitive performance and the director's ability to balance darkness with humor and airiness.
Read the full review →S
The Skinny
21 December 2023 · ★★★★★ · Stefania Sarrubba
100
The critic calls it a stunning return that empathetically captures a young woman's universal growing pains in extraordinary circumstances. It singles out Spaeny's subtle, breathing-as-emotional-outlet performance and the film's flawless soundtracking.
Read the full review →N
NME
4 September 2023 · festival review · Matthew Turner
90*
The review hails the film as a brilliant biopic that unflinchingly depicts the dark side of the relationship from Priscilla's viewpoint. It singles out the standout performances by Spaeny and Elordi along with Coppola's evocative soundtrack choices.
Read the full review →D
Den of Geek
12 October 2023 · ★★★★ · David Crow
80
The critic praises the film as a pensive character study that prioritizes Priscilla's interior perspective over Elvis myth-making. It singles out Cailee Spaeny's revelatory performance for conveying her gradual awakening to autonomy amid the imbalanced relationship.
Read the full review →F
Film Stories
29 September 2023 · festival review · Maria Lattila
80*
The film empathetically follows Priscilla through the highs and lows of her relationship with Elvis in a classic gilded cage story. It is visually stunning and acutely aching in its exploration of first love, with a luminous performance from Cailee Spaeny.
Read the full review →W
The Wrap
4 September 2023 · festival review
80*
Coppola’s lush and compassionate biopic offers a feminine, truth-telling counterpoint to myth-making by centering Priscilla’s perspective on her youthful devotion and isolation. Strong performances and period details shine, though the pacing loses coherence in the later sections.
Read the full review →D
Deadline
4 September 2023 · festival review · Stephanie Bunbury
70*
Coppola’s stylistic pizzazz overcomes the sense that the story is familiar by focusing on intimate details and shadowy interiors from Priscilla’s viewpoint. The film feels slight with no major revelations but finds meaning in small observations of the controlling relationship.
Read the full review →E
Eye for Film
9 October 2023 · festival review · Anne-Katrin Titze
70*
Coppola paints pictures of mid-century Americana and its moral shortcomings with a light touch that leaves space to draw conclusions about grooming and fame. The film explores the courtship between Elvis and teenage Priscilla through texture, colour, mood and telling details.
Read the full review →/
/Film
25 October 2023 · 6.5/10 · Shae Sennett
65
The film puts the audience inside young Priscilla's mind, showing a romance that becomes a gilded cage and a sobering portrait of Elvis as neither monster nor saint. It succeeds as a visceral emotional and textural experience but feels thinly woven in places.
Read the full review →C
Collider
10 October 2023 · C · Emma Kiely
57
The critic views the film as a disappointment that plays it safe and delivers a disjointed compilation of a toxic marriage rather than deeper insight into Priscilla's experience. The muted aesthetic and lack of Coppola's signature vibrancy are highlighted as major shortcomings despite strong lead performances.
Read the full review →P
Paste
27 October 2023 · 8.0 · Jesse Hassenger
The critic finds the film a strong fit for Coppola's style, offering a clear and purposeful look at Priscilla's gilded-cage life at Graceland that avoids overstaying its welcome. Spaeny's performance is singled out for its convincing portrayal of Priscilla across different ages.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate