Most critics are strongly enthusiastic about Psycho, with praise centred on Hitchcock’s control of audience expectations and his ability to make technical precision serve suspense. Anthony Perkins receives particular attention for a performance the reviews find both strong and nuanced, while Bernard Herrmann’s score and the editing are repeatedly singled out for their impact. Several critics also stress the bleak humour and psychological depth, finding more here than a succession of shocks.
The favourable reviews differ chiefly in emphasis: some value the mystery and entertainment, while others concentrate on voyeurism, desperation and the characters’ fears. Variety is more restrained, though it still admires the performances and technical work. The Guardian supplies the sharp dissent, finding the violence repellent, the characters difficult to care about and the mystery foolish. That objection separates it clearly from a consensus that regards Hitchcock’s manipulation as a principal strength.
