The critics split evenly, and few of them argue the film is anything more than a brisk, gory B-picture. What praise there is gathers around Milla Jovovich, whose Alice most reviews single out as a capable action lead, with Michelle Rodriguez close behind. The set pieces draw the warmest notices: the laser corridor sequence is mentioned more than any other scene, and several critics credit the production design and score for giving the underground facility atmosphere.
The reservations cluster on originality. Many critics call the plot a retread of Dawn of the Dead and Alien, the dialogue thin and the horror not frightening, with several noting it fails to reproduce the dread of the game. The spread is wide, from outright dismissal to enthusiastic defence. Empire and The AV Club are the harshest, finding the plotting incoherent and the tone humourless; Collider, writing later, is the most generous, treating it as a survival film that stands on its own.
