The reviews are unanimously positive, with praise centred on Audrey Hepburn’s performance as the sheltered princess and her chemistry with Gregory Peck. Critics repeatedly single out her naturalness, comic timing and ability to give the fairytale romance emotional weight. Peck’s understated playing provides a valued counterbalance, while William Wyler’s direction earns credit for keeping the comedy brisk without rushing the tender moments. The screenplay’s wit and the Rome location shooting are further points of agreement, giving the royal escape a lively, tangible setting.
The differences are chiefly in enthusiasm rather than judgement. The Telegraph finds the story slightly dated, though its individual moments remain affecting. The New Yorker is more reserved about the writing, describing a reliance on clichés, but finds Hepburn makes them work as comedy. Even these qualified responses retain considerable affection for the film; there is no substantial negative dissent among the reviews.
