Critics’ reviews

Rye Lane (2023)

25 reviews from 25 publications. Critics’ score 81: 18 positive, 0 mixed, 1 negative.

Back to our review of Rye Lane

81
Positive
18
Mixed
0
Negative
1

The reviews for Rye Lane are warm and unusually close together. Nearly every critic praises the same three things: the chemistry between the two leads, Raine Allen-Miller’s bright, restless direction in her first feature, and the film’s affection for Peckham and Brixton, which most treat as a character in its own right. The comparisons recur too; Before Sunrise and Richard Curtis are cited again and again, usually as a formula the film updates for a younger, Black British south London rather than one it overturns. Reservations are mild and cluster around the plot, which several find slight, and a final act that some think hurries. One review wishes the film were longer. The lone dissent comes from Slant Magazine, which grants the leads their charm but finds the screenplay flat and the picture of London closer to caricature than portrait, and says the romance never quite lands. Nobody else in the set is anywhere near that position.

Empire
16 March 2023 · John Nugent
85*

The critic finds the film utterly delightful and a fresh, energetic take on the rom-com genre. They single out the lively, stylish direction and the charismatic leads for praise while noting minor quibbles with the slight plot and final act.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
16 March 2023 · Charlotte O'Sullivan
85*

The critic hails it as the rom-com of the year and a vibrant love letter to Peckham that signals change for the genre. They praise the colourful, kinetic style and the human, flawed leads while highlighting the clever nod to Richard Curtis films.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
19 March 2023 · Peter Bradshaw
85*

The critic praises this vibrant debut feature as a hugely enjoyable romcom that blends warmth and charm with street-smart grit, creating something playful, poignant and personal. The leads are thrillingly engaging and the result leaves viewers with a smile and renewed confidence in British filmmaking.

Read the full review →
Vulture
1 April 2023
85*

The review commends the film for making romantic comedy look effortless with witty banter, chemistry between leads, and vibrant South London setting. Singles out the effortless feel and the city's energy for praise.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★★ · Emma Simmonds
80

This sparky British comedy puts a fresh spin on the Before Sunrise model as two strangers spend a day together on the streets of south London. It embraces the vibrancy of its setting with bold colours, larger-than-life characters, visual ingenuity and a very funny script.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
24 January 2023 · festival review · Jordan Mintzer
80*

The critic praises the film's charming meet-cute, charismatic leads, and fresh take on the rom-com genre set in South London, though it ultimately stays within genre conventions. Singles out the leads' banter and the vibrant Peckham setting for praise.

Read the full review →
The i Paper
17 March 2023 · Xuanlin Tham
80*

The review calls the film a fizzy, charming Gen-Z update to London rom-coms and an irresistible entry into the canon. It praises the effervescent portrait of south London life and the central couple's chemistry.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
16 March 2023
80*

The review hails the film as heralding a new generation of enchanting British romcoms, updating the Richard Curtis formula to contemporary south London with undisguised love for the place and its bustle. It captures the in-the-moment bliss of romance through gorgeous manoeuvres and a benedictory cameo.

Read the full review →
Variety
16 March 2023 · festival review · Guy Lodge
80*

Raine Allen-Miller’s immensely likable debut doesn't reinvent the wheel but instant chemistry between the stars keeps it spinning. It is an unabashed urban love letter to South London neighborhoods, claiming the rom-com for young Black Britain with breezy, infectiously young leads.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
30 March 2023 · B · Leigh Monson
77

The critic finds it a charming but slight British rom-com with winning leads, rich sense of place, and playful style. Singles out the natural chemistry of the leads and the neighborhood's depiction for praise, noting it's a promising debut despite being slight.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
24 January 2023 · festival review · Esther Zuckerman
75*

The review highlights how the film mashes up 'Before Sunrise' and Richard Curtis with fresh leads and a wonderful sense of place, delivering charm and fun. Praises the directorial debut for bolstering genre tropes effectively.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
29 January 2023 · festival review · David Robb
40*

The critic notes the charming leads but criticizes the flat screenplay, caricatured portrait of London, and failure to make the romance resonate fully. Singles out the visual flourishes and energy but complains about lack of depth.

Read the full review →
Financial Times
16 March 2023 · ★★★☆☆ · Leslie Felperin

The film is fizzy, smooth and sweet, poised to do for south London what Richard Curtis films did for other neighbourhoods, hitting all romcom marks while grounding the story in Gen Z problems. The combustible chemistry between the leads makes an engaging, believable love story.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
24 January 2023 · festival review

South London-set romantic comedy is a winner. Allen-Miller achieves the Holy Grail of great rom-coms in making us desperate to see the pair get together while not wanting the first flush of romance to end. It offers a warmly realised showcase for the charming leads.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
25 January 2023 · festival review

The engaging debut captures the fizz and vibrancy of Peckham and Brixton with a dash of Richard Curtis and Linklater. A confident, engaging debut that does not outstay its welcome despite occasional questions over character motivations.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
30 March 2023 · Critic’s Pick · Claire Shaffer

The director’s debut feature revives the rom-com genre with exuberant performances and a vibrant South London setting. It is self-assured, full of specificity in its details while the leads’ dreams and insecurities remain universal genre staples.

Read the full review →
The Times
17 March 2023 · ★★★★☆ · Kevin Maher

This is immediately one of the great London movies, a sweet and swoon-worthy metropolitan rom-com with deft construction, frothy energy and deep affection for its characters. The only minor complaint is that at 82 minutes it is almost too short.

Read the full review →
HeyUGuys
17 March 2023 · ★★★★★ · Emily Breen
100

The critic fell deeply in love with the central couple and their fizzy chemistry, calling the film an essential window into a vibrant, endangered corner of South London. They praise the leads' charm, the director's sense of place, and how it evokes the magic of a classic walk-and-talk romance.

Read the full review →
Collider
26 January 2023 · A- · Chase Hutchinson
90

The critic finds the film a sharply funny and inventive romantic comedy that crackles with energy throughout its sweet story. Vivian Oparah's comedic performance as Yas is singled out as the standout driving force.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
24 January 2023 · A- · Robert Daniels
90

The critic hails the debut as a wonder that immerses viewers in the verve of South London’s Peckham neighborhood through visual flair and bright spirit. They single out the breakout performances and the assured direction that makes familiar rom-com tropes feel fresh and infinitely rewatchable.

Read the full review →
Deadline
23 January 2023 · festival review · Anna Smith
85*

The critic calls Rye Lane a delight that breathes fresh life into the rom-com genre with youthful British energy and pays affectionate tribute to its forebears. She singles out the sunny, irreverent take on life and love, the strong supporting cast, and the imaginative visual flair in the storytelling.

Read the full review →
Digital Spy
3 May 2023 · Isabella Silvers
85*

Celebrates it as a joyous, authentic Black British rom-com full of energy, relatable characters, and vibrant South London settings.

Read the full review →
/Film
24 January 2023 · 8.5/10 · Ben Pearson
85

The critic finds the film a delightful, charming take on the walk-and-talk romance, full of lovable characters and a genuine love for its South London setting. They single out the leads' natural chemistry and the way the movie captures spontaneous, vibrant street life.

Read the full review →
NME
17 March 2023 · Kyann-Sian Williams
80*

The critic praises the likeable chemistry between leads and the quirky, visually inventive update to the romcom formula set in South London.

Read the full review →
Paste
31 March 2023 · 8.5 · Anna McKibbin

The critic calls it a perfectly poised romantic comedy that recrafts the genre with clarity of vision and specificity. The care for the central relationship and the vibrant South London setting are singled out for praise.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate