Most critics like Scott Walker: 30 Century Man, and the praise clusters in the same places: the access Kijak gets to a famously private musician, the archival performances, and the sequences in which fellow musicians listen to Walker’s records and react with open astonishment. Several reviewers see it as an affectionate tribute that will please longtime fans and send newcomers to the albums, and the animated interpretations of the songs are picked out as the film’s most distinctive touch.
The spread is wide. Two reviews pull hard against the rest: The Guardian finds the film painfully reverent, with a rock-nerd feel its graphics cannot disguise, while The Hollywood Reporter struggles to take it seriously and suggests its treatment of Walker’s perfectionism tips into absurdity. Even one of the admirers has doubts about Walker’s later music and some of the film’s choices. The reviews lean positive, but the dissenters are not mild.
