Critics’ reviews

Scrapper (2023)

25 reviews from 25 publications. Critics’ score 73: 14 positive, 3 mixed, 2 negative.

Back to our review of Scrapper

73
Positive
14
Mixed
3
Negative
2

Most critics like Scrapper, and nearly all of them, including the few who do not, agree on why it works when it does: Lola Campbell, a newcomer, and Harris Dickinson as the father who turns up uninvited, and the ease between them. Praise for Regan’s debut clusters around its colour and invention, the way it lets a twelve-year-old’s imagination interrupt a working-class setting, and around a grief story that stays light without going soft. The reservations gather in the same place. Several reviews find the whimsy twee or too cute, and the comparisons to Wes Anderson are not always meant kindly. The spread is wider than the score suggests. Slant Magazine argues the clash of realism and quirk undermines the film’s ideas about class and loss; The Hollywood Reporter finds the quirk strained and often irritating; The Times says the film never lands the emotional blow it reaches for. A few others simply find the errant-father story familiar.

The i Paper
25 August 2023 · Christina Newland
90*

The Sundance breakout is a lean, vivid working-class drama that balances social realism with imagination and low-key humour. It delivers a heart-piercing father-daughter story full of loving detail and gruff emotion.

Read the full review →
Empire
24 August 2023 · Ella Kemp
85*

The debut feature is a colourful, hopeful story of grief and father-daughter reconnection that avoids kitchen-sink clichés. It balances humour and tenderness with emotional intelligence and wit.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
25 August 2023 · Sheila O'Malley
85*

The critic praises the film's fluid tone blending whimsy, pathos, and humor in a story of a self-reliant girl and her immature father reconnecting after her mother's death. She highlights the authentic lead performances and inventive style as making for an impressive directorial debut.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
24 August 2023 · Charlotte O'Sullivan
80*

The film is a poignant Sundance prize-winner with dazzling performances from the young lead and director's fresh voice. It mixes whimsy and realism but has some twee and implausible moments.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
24 August 2023 · 4/4/4 · Hannah Strong
80

The critic finds it a charming, effervescent story about grief, praising the delightful chemistry between Campbell and Dickinson.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★★ · Max Copeman
80

The critic calls it an impressive debut with a charming comedy-drama, eccentric script, playful direction and striking chemistry between leads.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
29 January 2023 · festival review
80*

The critic praises the film's charming romp and magical realism, highlighting the fun father-daughter criminal partnership and flights of fantasy that elevate the debut.

Read the full review →
Time Out
3 August 2023 · ★★★★ · Phil de Semlyen
80

The critic praises the warm, freewheeling comedy-drama with rascally energy, noting it proves working-class stories can be joyful.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
23 January 2023 · festival review · Adam Solomons
75*

The review praises the low-key but high-spirited debut as a wise British charmer about a seemingly orphaned girl and her delinquent father, highlighting its appealing father-daughter dynamic.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
30 January 2023 · festival review
75*

The critic describes it as stylistically bold and youthful, a picture packed with ideas and fizzing energy in an unconventional urban fairytale.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
23 January 2023 · festival review · Leslie Felperin
40*

The critic views the film as a sweet but strained bit of fluff that tries too hard to be quirky and funny, often becoming annoying, though it benefits from strong performances by Harris Dickinson and newcomer Lola Campbell.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
21 August 2023 · Steven Scaife
35*

The critic sees the film as a baffling clash between kitchen-sink realism and twee indie dramedy that undermines its themes of grief and class with intrusive, ungrounded flights of fancy and generic scenes.

Read the full review →
Financial Times
24 August 2023 · ★★★★☆ · Jonathan Romney

The engagingly scrappy debut has plenty going for it, with an astonishing performance from newcomer Lola Campbell and bolshie joyousness at its best.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
19 August 2023 · Peter Bradshaw

The film offers a tender sweetness in its portrayal of a fragile father-daughter relationship, offset by visual dreaminess and warmth in the central performances.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
23 August 2023 · Critic's Pick · Claire Shaffer

The review calls the debut feature whip-smart, centering a capable 12-year-old who navigates life alone until her estranged father arrives and disrupts her routine. It commends the strong newcomer performance and the film's blend of comedy and drama in their evolving relationship.

Read the full review →
The Times
25 August 2023 · ★★☆☆☆ · Kevin Maher

The film fails to pack an emotional punch despite quirky sequences and the efforts of its lead actors, resulting in an underwhelming take on the errant-father formula.

Read the full review →
Variety
23 January 2023 · festival review · Guy Lodge

The critic describes it as a sweet, pastel-colored spin on British realism that benefits from Harris Dickinson's winning performance as a deadbeat dad. It notes the film's sunnier take on familiar territory but finds it occasionally too cute.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
25 January 2023 · B+ · Alani Vargas
83

The critic finds the film endearing in its portrayal of a grieving daughter's bond with her long-lost father, praising the imaginative perspective and strong lead performances. They single out the mix of realistic scenes with vibrant, quippy imaginative bursts that illustrate the child's viewpoint.

Read the full review →
/Film
24 August 2023 · 8/10 · Marshall Shaffer
80

The critic praises Regan's inventive direction that immerses viewers in the protagonist's imaginative world, highlighting the strong performances by Lola Campbell and Harris Dickinson in this father-daughter story. They single out the film's blend of whimsy and emotional depth as a standout.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
22 January 2023 · festival review · Elizabeth Weitzman
80*

The critic calls the film a lovely British drama about a grieving 12-year-old who believes she can raise herself and her estranged father who arrives to check on her. They praise Regan's empathetic direction and script, along with the standout performances of Harris Dickinson and newcomer Lola Campbell, while noting minor issues with exaggerated supporting characters.

Read the full review →
Collider
5 February 2023 · B- · Therese Lacson
70

The review calls it an uplifting if predictable feel-good story that benefits from strong lead chemistry and vibrant direction. The simplicity and charming performances make it effective despite lacking innovation.

Read the full review →
Deadline
25 January 2023 · festival review · Damon Wise
65*

The review portrays the film as a whimsical kitchen-sink drama dealing with grief, single parenting, and social care through candy-colored levity reminiscent of Wes Anderson. It praises the strong two-hander performances by Harris Dickinson and Lola Campbell but finds it occasionally flippant or baffling given the vulnerable subject matter.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
6 February 2023 · ★★★ · Jeremy Mathews
60

The critic notes the film's ambitious mix of social realism with whimsical elements inspired by Wes Anderson, commending the cast but finding some choices off-putting and the tone uneven. They single out the vibrant color palette and playful tone amid working-class hardships for praise.

Read the full review →
The Skinny
22 August 2023 · ★★★ · Stefania Sarrubba
60

Scrapper puts a joyous spin on working-class stories with a tender father-daughter dramedy that doesn't overstay its welcome. The movie's secret weapon is its leading duo, with effortless chemistry between Campbell and Dickinson finding levity and hope in unexpected places.

Read the full review →
Paste
25 August 2023 · 6.1 · Jacob Oller

The critic finds the father-daughter story familiar and overly conventional with little emotional specificity, though it hangs together as a brief debut. Dickinson's grounded performance stands out amid the twee elements and strong locations.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate