The reviews split almost down the middle, and a score in the mid-fifties reflects an argument rather than a shrug. Where most critics agree is on the humour: the in-jokes, the Hollywood film-set satire and the cameos are the elements singled out most often, and even the harsher notices grant it a few sharp gags. The cast draws steady approval, with Radio Times picking out Posey and Fisher and Roger Ebert praising Neve Campbell’s screen presence.
The reservations cluster on the horror. Several critics find the jolts mechanical, the plot over-stuffed and the sense of danger absent; Time Out calls it a poor copy of New Nightmare, and The AV Club sees Craven going through the motions. Sight and Sound finds the killer’s reveal weak. The spread is wide, from the Los Angeles Times, which finds it scary and amusing, to Paste, which calls it a mess. Film Stories, writing much later, argues the film has been misjudged.
