With only 3 reviews in so far, the reviews lean warm but the spread is wide. Most critics take it as an unusually assured debut, praising Soderbergh’s script for its patience with adultery and voyeurism, and the performances for feeling like people rather than positions; several single out the video camera itself as a character. Some note the technical limits of a low budget without minding much. The one clear dissent comes from The New Yorker, which grants the film its polish and its knack for tension from small materials but finds it a triangle drama with a minor kink, arriving at platitudes about honesty and feelings.
The critic finds the film startling in its handling of taboo subjects like adultery and voyeurism through 1980s technology, and startlingly competent as a debut that won the Palme d'Or. The believable characters and Soderbergh's intriguingly intellectual script are singled out for praise.
Read the full review →