Most critics welcome Shallow Grave as an assured, fast-moving black-comic thriller, with praise clustering around Danny Boyle’s direction, the tightly framed interiors and the lead performances. The reviews find energy and invention in its confined setting, while John Hodge’s screenplay earns credit for keeping the moral dilemma moving towards nastier consequences. Ewan McGregor receives particular attention, and the strongest notices enjoy the characters’ greed and unpleasantness as much as the macabre humour.
The spread runs from enthusiastic approval to mixed responses, with characterisation the main dividing line. RogerEbert.com finds the central trio too unpleasant and boring to sustain involvement, despite flashes of visual style. The Los Angeles Times objects to the sealed-off atmosphere and strained sophistication. Other reservations concern excessive cleverness and a diminishing comic edge as the violence increases: most critics enjoy the film’s sourness, but the dissenters find too little to engage with beyond its technique.
