The reviews are mixed, and the spread is fairly wide. Almost every critic praises Jeremy Allen White, describing a raw, internalised performance that gets at Springsteen’s depression rather than his stage persona, and several single out his singing. The decision to confine the film to the making of Nebraska is also broadly welcomed as a relief from the career-spanning biopic, with the father-son scenes and the bond between Springsteen and his manager named as the most convincing material. The reservations cluster around drama: many find the film short on narrative drive, tension and context, stronger on atmosphere than incident, and several say it falls back on familiar music-film beats and occasionally weak dialogue. The Guardian objects to an invented romantic subplot it finds derivative, and The Ringer is the sharpest dissenter, calling the film timid and artificial while still crediting White. Even the warmest notices concede an uneven opening and a sag in the later depressive stretch.
The film starts unevenly but comes alive when focusing on the creation of Nebraska, delivering a strong central performance from Jeremy Allen White that captures Springsteen's vulnerability and trauma.
Read the full review →