The reviews are unanimous in their approval: every critic who has written on Star Trek IV counts it a success, and several call it the most enjoyable entry in the series. The praise gathers around the comedy. Critics single out the fish-out-of-water scenes in 1980s San Francisco, the interplay between Shatner and Nimoy, and the decision to build the film around the crew’s relationships rather than action. Nimoy’s direction is credited with a lighter, more irreverent tone that critics say brings the films closer to the original television series.
Reservations are mild and scattered. The AV Club finds the film lacks the edge of earlier entries, and The New York Times notes technical shortcomings beneath the sincerity. The Guardian calls the environmentalism half-baked, though it enjoys the film regardless. The spread is narrow, from good to excellent, and nobody dissents from the view that this is the warmest and most accessible of the series.
