Nearly every critic comes away pleased, and the reviews agree on why. The film returns to the spirit of the original trilogy after the prequels: fast, funny, and made with visible affection. The praise clusters on the new cast, with Daisy Ridley’s Rey named most often and John Boyega and Adam Driver close behind. One review finds the acting stronger than in any earlier Star Wars film, and the BB-8 droid gets a warm mention.
Reservations cluster on how much the film leans on nostalgia. Several critics note the callbacks; The Wrap goes further and says Abrams has more or less remade the first film, and Film Comment finds the second half runs out of tension for the same reason. Pacing draws a few complaints, as do underused characters, Poe Dameron among them. The spread is narrow, with the Los Angeles Times the only real dissent, finding the film erratic and only intermittently successful, with Harrison Ford its strongest element.
