The consensus is firmly negative: all eight reviews find Superman IV: The Quest for Peace a weak sequel, with cheap-looking effects, sluggish storytelling and little of the earlier films’ humour. Praise is sparse and centres on the performers, particularly Christopher Reeve and Hackman’s occasional laughs. Even sympathetic notices find those contributions overwhelmed by weak plotting and poor production values. The anti-nuclear message offers little compensation, coming across as either buried or heavy-handed.
The differences concern what remains worth defending, rather than whether the film succeeds. The Hollywood Reporter finds some spectacular action amid the flatness, while most critics treat the effects as a central failing. The Los Angeles Times credits the cast with retaining a playful grip on their roles; Variety finds most of them going through the motions. The spread is narrow, with even the less hostile reviews offering scant encouragement.
