Most critics like it, though few love it. Twelve of seventeen reviews are positive, and the praise lands on the same things: the action set pieces, the long crane chase in particular, and Arnold Schwarzenegger, whom several reviewers find on better form than expected. Jonathan Mostow gets credit for pace, for a lighter comic touch than the series has shown before, and for an ending that more than one critic calls surprisingly dark and bold.
The reservations cluster just as tightly. The commonest complaint is that the film retreads the plot of the earlier entries without their dread or ideas, and that Mostow, however capable, lacks James Cameron’s gift for making an audience fear for the characters. The spread runs from strong approval to outright dismissal; The New Yorker finds it a numbing spectacle and Time Out a cheesy retread. Later reassessments from Den of Geek and Collider are kinder than most of the 2003 notices.
