Critics’ reviews

The Blind Side (2009)

20 reviews from 20 publications. Critics’ score 53: 6 positive, 6 mixed, 8 negative.

Back to our review of The Blind Side

53
Positive
6
Mixed
6
Negative
8

The reviews split almost evenly, but nearly all of them agree on one thing: Sandra Bullock. Critics who dislike the film still describe her Leigh Anne Tuohy as forceful, energetic and the reason to watch, and several say she carries a picture that would otherwise sink. The warmer notices, mostly from the American trade press and the more populist British sites, take it as old-fashioned comfort food with a few funny supporting scenes and solid football sequences.

The reservations cluster on race. Many critics find the film sugar-coated and simplistic, but the sharper objection is that it turns a true story into a tale of white charity, leaving the Black teenager at its centre as a cipher with little agency. The AV Club and Slant Magazine are harshest on this point. The spread is wide, running from warm recommendations to outright dismissal, and The Guardian dissents even on Bullock, finding her almost insufferable.

Los Angeles Times
20 November 2009 · Betsy Sharkey
85*

The review praises the film as an old-style, hopeful story full of heart and humor that succeeds as a satisfying success tale. Bullock's sassy, empathetic lead performance is singled out as the standout element.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★★ · Karen Krizanovich
80

This heartfelt drama shows how good deeds change lives at all levels through the story of a wealthy woman sheltering a homeless teen. It avoids melodrama to deliver a charming and inspiring tale.

Read the full review →
Variety
15 November 2009 · Joe Leydon
80*

The critic calls it an uplifting, entertaining feel-good sports drama that remains involving and emotionally honest despite some sugar-coating. It is praised for its insightful take on racial and political realities in the South.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
10 April 2012
65*

The review calls the film sentimental but effective as an inspirational Hollywood drama, highlighting Bullock's freewheeling performance and the solid football scenes while noting some dramatic licence.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
15 November 2009 · Michael Rechstshaffen
65*

The film sticks to conventional inspirational sports-movie formulas while sidelining deeper sociological issues, but delivers crowd-pleasing entertainment through strong performances. Bullock shines as the determined Southern mother in this fact-based story.

Read the full review →
Empire
24 February 2010 · Ian Freer
60*

The film is described as a sugar-coated mix of sports clichés and crusading drama that stretches credibility, but Bullock's towering, versatile performance saves it and makes it moving despite the lack of nuance.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
19 November 2009 · A.O. Scott
60*

The critic views the film as a heartwarming but overly simplistic Disney-style tale of a foundling taken in by a generous family. Bullock's forceful performance dominates the proceedings.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
12 January 2010
50*

The film has its heart in the right place but offers a simplistic treatment that combines sports drama and inspirational tropes without digging deeply. It works best early on thanks to Bullock's performance but becomes predictable.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
19 November 2009 · D · Scott Tobias
37

The film sinks to a new low in well-meaning white paternalism by portraying the Black protagonist as a simpleton in need of rescue by a white family. It simplifies complex race and class dynamics into an old-fashioned, condescending narrative.

Read the full review →
The Independent
26 March 2010
35*

The critic praises Sandra Bullock's energetic performance but criticizes the film for lacking drama, distilling a true story into simplistic Disney-like syrup with minimal conflict or depth in the central relationship.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
*** · Sukhdev Sandhu
30*

Sandra Bullock stomps through her scenes in a deliberately mushy exercise in sentimentality more interested in white people's feelings than politics or the black protagonist's story. The film is a deliberately obfuscatory feelgood tale that assumes the viewer identifies with the adoptive mother.

Read the full review →
The Times
27 March 2010 · Kate Muir
30*

The film is a modern-day Pygmalion financed by Taco Bell; Bullock gives a terrific ball-breaking performance but the rest is painfully patronising with the black lead left as a cipher manipulated by others.

Read the full review →
Time Out
23 March 2010 · Trevor Johnston
30*

The film fails to explore its themes of kindness and social divides, instead becoming a star vehicle that panders to white middle-class viewers with clichés. It offers a half-truth rather than a deeper story.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
19 November 2009 · Aaron Cutler
20*

The manipulative story celebrates white charity rescuing a Black teen while stripping him of agency and reinforcing stereotypes about race and class. Skillful filmmaking and performances cannot redeem its loathsome, prejudicial worldview.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
28 March 2010 · Peter Bradshaw
20*

The critic finds Sandra Bullock's performance almost insufferable in this feelgood football movie about a rich white family adopting a homeless black teen and turning him into a star player. It is seen as a patronising, loaded portrayal of the New South with a touch of backlash politics.

Read the full review →
HeyUGuys
22 March 2010 · Andy Petrou
85*

The critic praises Sandra Bullock's standout, Oscar-worthy performance as the sassy and inspirational Leigh Anne Tuohy and highlights the film's feel-good sports drama elements along with strong ensemble chemistry.

Read the full review →
Den of Geek
4 January 2010 · ★★★★ · Ron Hogan
80

The critic praises the film as warm, uplifting comfort food buoyed by Sandra Bullock's charming lead performance and some surprisingly funny supporting scenes.

Read the full review →
Digital Spy
22 March 2010 · Simon Reynolds
75*

The critic highlights Bullock's standout sassy and heartfelt performance as the force driving this uplifting family drama about against-all-odds personal triumph, though notes one overly cutesy supporting character as a misstep.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
22 March 2010 · Owen Van Spall
55*

The critic notes the film's polished packaging and Bullock's strong presence but criticizes its saccharine tone, avoidance of deeper racial and emotional tensions, and white-savior narrative.

Read the full review →
Paste
4 March 2010 · Christina Lee
40*

The critic views the film as mild-tempered, family-friendly comfort food that falls short of Best Picture contention, lacking a defining moment or revolutionary qualities. They single out its portrayal of relationships and the lead performance for mild praise but criticize the lack of depth in character development and overall blandness.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate